Peabody to Build a Considerable Portfolio at Our Tribes' Expense
As you may know, the Hopi Tribe and Navajo Nation entered into three separate leases with Sentry Royalty Company (predecessor to Peabody Western Coal) beginning in the mid-1960s. The Navajo Nation has a "Navajo Exclusive" lease (No. 8580) and shares another lease with the Hopi Tribe (No. 9910). Peabody pays 12.5 percent of monthly gross realization (royalty) on Lease 8580 to Navajo; and pays 6.25 percent monthly gross realization to both Hopi and Navajo under Lease 9910.
The leases now provide for renegotiation every 10 years, referred to as "Lease Reopener." Lease 9910 has not been formally approved by Hopi although it was due for renewal in 2007. Navajo approved its portions in April 2011.
Coal from the Black Mesa Mine was dedicated to the Mohave Generating Station (MGS), but MGS shut its operations in 2005. Today, very little if any mining is occurring in the Black Mesa Mine area. Coal mined on the Kayenta Mine area is delivered to NGS and royalties are shared by the two tribes under Lease 9910 Lease; and Navajo receives all royalties under is lease, No. 8580.
Since the inception of the leases, Peabody Coal has not paid Hopi and Navajo at current fair market prices for the coal it mined and the water it pumped for mining operations. During its heyday, Peabody pumped over 3.3 million gallons each day from our precious Navajo Aquifer to slurry coal, over 275 miles from Black Mesa to MGS in Laughlin, Nev. Since it began mining, Peabody mined over 400 million tons of coal from the Black Mesa and Kayenta mines.
If you review the leases, you will find the leases provided only for leasing of surface acres. No consideration was made on the value of the massive coal and water deposits that were the subject of the leases. No appraisals or valuation of the coal and water deposits were made to determine the fair market value of these resources. As a result, the tribes lost millions, if not billions, of revenues since the inception of the leases. Yet, by virtue of the leases, Peabody obtained exclusive subsurface rights to our vast deposits of coal and water without paying a dime for them. We (the tribes and the federal government) allowed Peabody to build a considerable company portfolio at our expense. This coal and water became an asset to Peabody that it would leverage for other business ventures. Tribal coal and water were "locked in" for the duration of the leases and tribes could not re-negotiate the terms of the leases, or could they leverage the resources. The leases effectively kept the tribes from diversifying their respective economies because the tribes lost control over the resources.
In a typical business scenario, a company would buy raw materials that it would use in manufacturing its products. Not so under the Peabody coal leases. The tribes received no upfront payments for the coal and water Peabody secured under the leases. Instead, tribes are compensated minimally (12.5 percent and 6.25 percent gross monthly realization) when Peabody sells the coal to NGS. Incidentally, the royalty rates were the subject of the Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO), which is a matter for later discussion.
Peabody and owners of NGS receive considerable benefits from the production and sale of electricity using our coal and water. Yet the tribes do not participate in the sharing of profits. The value chart depicts that owners of NGS (Arizona Public Service, Tucson Gas and Electric, Bureau of Reclamation, Salt River Project, Los Angeles Water and Power, and Nevada Power) are also "customers" of NGS.
Concerning tax revenues, while the Navajo Nation and the State of Arizona receive some tax revenues, the Hopi Tribe receives no tax revenues because it does not impose taxes on Peabody because of a reported covenant to not tax Peabody. In its 2005 report, Peabody reported that the Navajo Nation received over $82.9 million in various forms of taxes during the period 1986 to 2004, while the state of Arizona received over $67.5 million during the same period.
Payments made by Peabody are not commensurate with the profits they earn from our resources. Hopi only receives about $11.0 million to $13.0 million in royalties and other benefits each year from Peabody, very little, if any, of which goes to our people. But Peabody reported that its revenues rose 21 percent to a record $2 billion; and its operating profits rose 41 percent to $458 million for the quarter ending June 2011. Peabody's chairman and chief executive officer alone received a salary of $11.9 million in 2009; and its executive vice president and chief financial officer earned $4.1 million. And the Salt River Project recently reported a profit of over 26 percent in 2011.
After almost 50 years of mining, we have nothing to show how the mining of our coal and the pumping of our precious Navajo Aquifer has benefited us. Simply look around. We have dilapidated infrastructure, dismal housing conditions, limited water supply, contaminated drinking water, limited scholarships, limited or no jobs, etc. Our socioeconomic conditions remain dismal while Peabody, NGS and their holding companies make significant profits from our resources. It is time to make a change in the structure of the coal leases so that our tribe, our villages, and our people can all benefit from sale of our resources:
• Demand upfront payments for coal and water that will be the subject of the leases on an annual basis at fair market prices.
• Increase the monthly royalties to reflect current fair market rates (instead of a minimum 12.5 percent and 6.25 percent).
• Demand that Peabody complies with the leases and find alternative sources of water, other than using the Navajo Aquifer; and reclaim and repair the area including damages to the aquifers.
• Limit the leases to coal and water, and exclude other "kindred" products.
• Enact a tax ordinance and begin imposing possessory interest taxes, business activity taxes, sales taxes, fuel excise taxes, severance taxes, etc. on Peabody.
• Hold Peabody accountable for damage done to our resources, including damages to our archaeological resources.
• If Peabody refuses to amend its lease and agree to these conditions, seek competition to find a more responsible and accountable lessee.
• Develop alternative uses of our resources and transition to use of alternative energy.
• And impose on the Secretary of Interior Salazar to declare that material damage has occurred on Black Mesa and the Navajo Aquifer. There is clear evidence of damages done to our resources.
This column was originally published in the Navajo-Hopi Observer on Dec. 14, 2011.
Benjamin Nuvamsa is the former chairman of the Hopi Tribe.