Header

Joint Statement in Opposition to Book Censorship in Tucson Unified School District

Various
1/30/12

The undersigned organizations are committed to protecting free speech and intellectual freedom. We write to express our deep concern about the removal of books used in the Mexican-American Studies Program in the Tucson Unified School District. This occurred in response to a determination by Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction John Huppenthal that the program “contained content promoting resentment toward a race or class of people” and that “materials repeatedly reference white people as being ‘oppressors….’ in violation of state law.” The books have been boxed up and put in storage; their fate and that of the program remain in limbo.

The First Amendment is grounded on the fundamental rule that government officials, including public school administrators, may not suppress “an idea simply because society finds the idea itself offensive or disagreeable.” School officials have a great deal of authority and discretion to determine the curriculum, the subject of courses, and even methods of instruction. They are restrained only by the constitutional obligation to base their decisions on sound educational grounds, and not on ideology or political or other personal beliefs. Thus, school officials are free to debate the merits of any educational program, but that debate does not justify the wholesale removal of books, especially when the avowed purpose is to suppress unwelcome information and viewpoints.

School officials have insisted that the books haven’t been banned because they are still available in school libraries. It is irrelevant that the books are available in the library—or at the local bookstore. School officials have removed materials from the curriculum, effectively banning them from certain classes, solely because of their content and the messages they contain. The effort to “prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, [or] religion” is the essence of censorship, whether the impact results in removal of all the books in a classroom, seven books, or only one.

Students deserve an education that provides exposure to a wide range of topics and perspectives, including those that are controversial. Their education has already suffered from this political and ideological donnybrook, which has caused massive disruption in their classes and will wreak more havoc as teachers struggle to fill the educational vacuum that has been created.

Book-banning and thought control are antithetical to American law, tradition and values. In Justice Louis Brandeis's famous words, the First Amendment is founded on the belief:

that freedom to think as you will and to speak as you think are means indispensable to the discovery and spread of political truth; that, without free speech and assembly, discussion would be futile; … that it is hazardous to discourage thought, hope and imagination …. Believing in the power of reason as applied through public discussion, [the Framers] eschewed silence coerced by law …. Recognizing the occasional tyrannies of governing majorities, they amended the Constitution so that free speech and assembly should be guaranteed.

The First Amendment right to read, speak and think freely applies to all, regardless of race, ethnicity, sex, religion, or national origin. We strongly urge Arizona school officials to take this commitment seriously and to return all books to classrooms and remove all restrictions on ideas that can be addressed in class.

American Association of University Professors

Cary Nelson, President

1133 19th St., NW, Suite 200

Washington, D.C. 20036

202-737-5900

cnelson@illinois.edu

American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression

Chris Finan, President

19 Fulton Street, Suite 407

New York, NY 10038

212-587-4025

chris@abffe.org

American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Arizona

Alessandra Soler Meetze, Executive Director

P.O. Box 17148

Phoenix, AZ 85011-0148

602-773-6006

ameetze@acluaz.org

Antigone Books

Trudy Mills and Kate Randall, Owners

411 N. 4th Ave.

Tucson, AZ 85705

520-792-3715

info@antigonebooks.com

Association of American Publishers

Judith Platt

Director, Free Expression Advocacy

455 Massachusetts Avenue, NW

Washington, D.C. 20001

202-220-4551

jplatt@publishers.org

Association of American University Presses

Peter Givler, Executive Director

28 West 36th Street, Suite 602

New York, NY 10018

212-989-1010

pgivler@aaupnet.org

Atalanta’s Music & Books

Joan Werner, Owner

38 Main Street

Bisbee, AZ 85603

520-432-9976

Authors Guild

Paul Aiken, Executive Director

31 East 32nd Street, 7th Floor

New York, NY 10016

212-563-5904

PAiken@authorsguild.org

Center for Expansion of Language and Thinking

Dr. Kathryn F. Whitmore, President

N275 Lindquist Center

The University of Iowa

Iowa City, IA 52242

319-335-5434

Kathryn-whitemore@uiowa.edu

Changing Hands Bookstore

Gayle Shanks, Bob Sommer and Cindy Dach, Owners

6428 S McClintock Drive

Tempe, AZ 85283

480-730-0205

inbox@changinghands.com

Comic Book Legal Defense Fund

Charles Brownstein, Executive Director

255 West 36th Street, Suite 501

New York, NY 10018

212-679-7151

charles.brownstein@cbldf.org

Freedom to Read Foundation, an affiliate of the American Library Association

Barbara M. Jones, Executive Director

50 East Huron Street

Chicago, IL 60611

312-280-4226

bjones@ala.org

International Reading Association

Richard M. Long, Ed.D.,

Director, Government Relations

444 North Capitol Street, NW, Suite 524

Washington, DC 20001

(202) 624-8801

rlong@reading.org

Mountains and Plains Independent Booksellers Association

Laura Ayrey, Executive Director

8020 Springshire Drive

Park City, UT 84098

435-649-6079

laura@mountainsplains.org

National Coalition Against Censorship

Joan Bertin, Executive Director

19 Fulton Street, Suite 407

New York, NY 10038

212-807-6242

bertin@ncac.org

National Council for the Social Studies

Susan Griffin, Executive Director

8555 16th St, Ste 500

Silver Spring, MD 20910

301.588.1800 x 103

sgriffin@ncss.org

National Council of Teachers of English

Millie Davis

Senior Developer, Affiliated Groups and Public Outreach

1111 West Kenyan Road

Urbana, IL 61801

800-369-6283 ext. 3634

mdavis@ncte.org

National Youth Rights Association

Alex Koroknay-Palicz, Executive Director

1101 15th Street, NW Suite 200

Washington, DC 20005

202-835-1739

akpalicz@youthrights.org

PEN American Center

Larry Siems, Director, Freedom to Write & International Programs

588 Broadway

New York, NY 10012

212-334-1660 ext. 105

lsiems@pen.org

PEN Center USA

Adam Somers, Executive Director

P.O. Box 6037

Beverly Hills, CA 90212

323-424-4939

adam@penusa.org

People For the American Way

Debbie Liu, General Counsel

1101 15th Street NW, Suite 600

Washington, D.C. 20005

202-467-4999

dliu@pfaw.org

Reach Out and Read

Anne-Marie Fitzgerald

Senior Director of National and State Programs

56 Roland Street, Suite 100D

Boston, MA 02129

618-455-0600

Reading is Fundamental, Inc.

Carol Hampton Rasco, President/CEO

1255 23rd Street NW, Suite 300

Washington, DC 20037

202-536-3500

Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators

Lin Oliver, Executive Director

8271 Beverly Boulevard

Los Angeles, CA 90048

323-782-1010

linoliver@scbwi.org

Spark Teacher Education Institute

Educational Praxis, Inc.

P.O. Box 409

Putney, Vermont 05346

802-258-9212

Student Press Law Center

Frank LoMonte, Executive Director

1101 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 1100

Arlington, VA 22209-2275 USA

703-807-1904

flomonte@splc.org

TESOL International Association

John Segota, CAE

Associate Executive Director for Public Policy & Professional Relations

1925 Ballenger Ave., Suite 550

Alexandria, VA 22314

703-518-2513

jsegota@tesol.org

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

2

POST A COMMENT

Comments

curtj's picture
If you care to google "Low Intelligence and Conservatism" it may give the Indignous a glimpse of why the European descendants continue to foist their ancestors policies of colonialism, with its theft and murder on the Indigenous, stealing our minerals, resources and lands. Per a study by the Brock University of Toronto, low intelligence & conservative ideals linked to prejudice. Low level education as children is linked to low intelligence adults who tend to gravitate toward socially conservative idealogies, claimed Gordon Hodson, which in turn, stress hierarchy and resistance to change, attitudes which can contribut to prejudice. I read an article which said that the conservatives tend to be dumb. Also the ones pushing their religiosity on others. What an enlightenment, I knew something about it for years but wasn't able to put it into perspective. Maybe the Indigenous leaders could bring it up, if they weren't chicken sh-t to do it. It appears the Indigenous leaders refuse to think outside the box the descendants of the illegal European immigrants put the Indigenous in. Imagine, they can bring our grievances to the Indigenous peoples Forum of the United Nations, but they refuse to do it. I think they are stuck on making losing to the thieves and murderers a career without doing anything to point us in the right direction to righting the wrongs foisted on us.
curtj
tmsyr11's picture
The United States still was a great country and society though considering if the North Americas weren't developed, those low-IQ indigenous peoples would be clamoring to get into.....Canada. For centuries your indigenous values have failed to surface successfully, i.e. standards of living, equality and pursuit of happiness. This explains why 'everyone and their grandma are crossing the US border illegal to get in. I don' see any-one leaving, have you seen anyone? Who has allowed the thefts to occur, i.e. stealing minerals, resources, and lands? Tribal elected officials representative of the electoral but more importantly clanship and family ties! If not for conservative values and principles (instead of this pro-regressive ideology pervasive in such countries as Cuba and Venazaula) the United States would not have attained a greater success based on opportunity. I'm sorry but I vehemently disagree with your comment and only hope and wish people would clamor more for the truth than jumping on this band-wagon of hate and discontent based on extremism from south of the border.
tmsyr11