Header

The Gymnastics of Patriotism

Steve Russell
8/19/12

I've been watching and thinking about Gabby Douglas, the teenage heroine of the London Olympics. Or so I view her. I was thinking of Olga Korbut, Nadia Comaneci, Mary Lou Retton, Shannon Miller—all young girls who taught us that tough is not just a masculine trait.

I was looking forward to seeing Gabby Douglas on the Wheaties box. I have granddaughters.

Then there was the uproar about her hair. Really, America?

Then there was the uproar about her mother's bankruptcy. Hey, America, if Gabby's mom had the sum the Romneys spent training and feeding Rafalca the dressage horse, she would not have gone bankrupt. I hate to break it to you, but since 2008 a lot of hard working people have gone bankrupt in lesser endeavors than boosting a daughter towards Olympic gold.

And I mean no disrespect toward Rafalca. As the Cherokee cowboy Will Rogers said, “A man that don’t love a horse, there’s something the matter with him.” It may be a rich man’s sport, but Rafalca is a fine animal and if she were mine, wild horses could not keep me from watching her dance.

Now there's an uproar that Gabby Douglas wore a pink leotard rather than red, white, or blue. Like Michelle Obama before her, she's "unpatriotic," goes the narrative.

What is this urge white Americans always have for black Americans, not to mention American Indians, to prove their "patriotism?" America, your involuntary citizens from Africa or Native America prove their patriotism every day they don't set out to kill you.

And if that's shocking, and you just can't wrap your mind around the history of white people vis-a-vis black people and Indians, then can you wrap your mind around the history of disturbed individuals and mass murder?

Make yourself two lists.

Including political motivations or not is arguable, since people who commit mass murder for political reasons are in my view no less disturbed, but I understand reasonable people can differ.

Put aside those who kill without racial selection of victims.

But then you are left with how many times a black or an Indian since, say, Nat Turner, has set out on a mission of wholesale slaughter of white people.

Now think about how many disturbed white people have engaged in wholesale slaughter of black people or Indians, and to be fair in light of the last paragraph we can exclude Chivington and Custer. Wounded Knee I, a massacre of noncombatant Indians in 1890, might be a fair cut off date, since that also excludes the Civil War.

You can even put the Asian guy who shot up Virginia Tech in the "general racial minority" category, even though it dulls the point of historical injustice. Asians have suffered racial injustice big time, but as purposeful immigrants. American Indians are not immigrants and African-Americans were imported to serve whites.

Go ahead, use Professor Google. Make your own lists by your own standards.

How many minority mass killers targeted whites, and how many white mass killers targeted minorities?

"Patriotism" in the American context is fidelity to the constitutional principle of peaceful coexistence with others not like you, whether they are different in what they believe or different in how their bodies appear.

There is something cockamamie in the way white people deploy the term "patriotism" as a cudgel against blacks and against American Indians. This cudgel comes into play whenever the disfavored minorities do something to win the admiration of the American public. I am reminded of the jihad against the great Sac and Fox Olympian, Wa-Tho-Huk, also known as Jim Thorpe.

If I point out this inconsistent public discourse, I will of course be accused of “playing the race card,” a term that entered the American political lexicon when OJ Simpson proved that a rich black man could buy as much “justice” in America as a rich white man. Google T. Cullen Davis.

And I still want to see Gabby Douglas, in whatever hairstyle makes her comfortable, on a Wheaties box.

Steve Russell, Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma, is a Texas trial court judge by assignment and associate professor emeritus of criminal justice at Indiana University-Bloomington. He lives in Georgetown, Texas.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

12

POST A COMMENT

Comments

swrussel's picture
The "elder" gave you bad advice. You don't learn to think for yourself by avoiding propaganda. You engage it head on. That's how to teach your kids. I will agree that an unsupervised TV in a household with tiny children is prima facie evidence of child abuse. We didn't get a TV until I was in the fourth grade, and starting then I probably watched too much--but I already had developed an attention span beyond the 15 minutes TV shapes. So I raised my kids the same way, TV rationed until they had the attention span thing worked out. I'm not concerned with writing "red." I'm concerned with writing correctly. If, in your universe, race-baiting stands in for political argument, it's not somewhere I want to live. I know this column will be called race-baiting in some circles. I don't think that's the case, but since you haven't read it, I won't bore you with why I think my comments are fair.
swrussel
hjwjc's picture
First and foremost I like Steve Russell's style of writing, may not always agree with him, but he is a good writer. My television story is/was: Our mother threw the television out of the house when I was about 12, because, like the coke bottle on the "Gods must be Crazy" it, the "TV", was causing fights... I don't think one learns how to think for themselves by watching television. Anyway... One of the first times I ever heard someone use race as a reason for a tribal member's success was from a person who was raised on the reservation, a daughter from a white Trading Post family. This white woman said, "The reason why that tribal member is a success is because they're part white." Not because they are red or read, whatever. Isn't it just like the media to find something to critize a person of "color" about.(Or anyone for that matter.) If not her pink tights, then her hair, it would have been something. Personally I didn't see the pink or the hair. I saw a very good gymnast, like Olga Korbut, Nadia Comaneci, etc. Then again there are some out there who might think otherwise. Be nice to see Ms. Douglas challenge whoever to the floor exercise, balance beam and other routines. I am glad you spoke up.
hjwjc

Pages