Remember: There Was Genocide in the United States, Too

Steve Melendez

On the National Mall in Washington D.C there is the Jewish Holocaust Museum. Most people have only a superficial knowledge of what this museum stands for. You may, like I did, believe that it contained only images of dead bodies, stacked like cordwood and that it really wasn’t something I wanted to see. Why there is such a need for such a thing is a question that is left hanging in the space of our collective consciousness. Then when you finally go, you find that your understanding was just the tip of the iceberg.

Like the Egyptian “Art of Memory” practiced by the Freemasons in their lodges, the tour takes you from one chamber of thought to another. It begins with photographs of ordinary people, family photos, a youngster holding a violin. In the late 1930s the Jews in Europe were ordinary human beings living their lives unaware that they would soon be the objects of extermination. The first shock to your worldview comes as you read a quote on a plaque by Martin Luther who started the Reformation, “ …to set fire to their synagogues or schools and to bury and cover with dirt whatever will not burn…I advise that their houses be razed and destroyed...that all cash and treasure of silver and gold be taken from them…”. One of the greatest lessons to be learned here is that wars and genocide begin in the hearts and words of seemingly righteous men. Moving on, we read of the laws which outlawed Germans from marrying Jews. There were laws which prevented Jews from holding civil service jobs, and laws which stripped them of all their rights including the right to own property. We are told that in Austria, ‘Aryan Austrians’ submitted applications to acquire former Jewish owned businesses. By the time you reach the part of the tour dealing with the deportment of the Jews to the concentration camps, you get a sense of deja vu. If you leave the Jewish Holocaust Museum with an eerie feeling that the Jewish Holocaust and American history are somehow connected, you are right. Not only did Hitler pattern his land grabbing policy of lebensraum (living space) after the ethnic cleansing and genocide of the American Indians, but he referred to the indigenous Slavs as “redskins."

Why is there a need for the Jewish Holocaust Museum? Does it exist in order “to play the guilt card”? Are reparations the goal? No, the purpose of the Holocaust Museum is to prevent history from repeating itself. Likewise, our museum, the American Indian Genocide Museum here in Houston, Texas exists for the same reason. Currently we have been protesting the Buffalo Soldiers Museum, also located here in Houston. The Buffalo Soldiers take great pride in dressing up in Cavalry uniforms and parading around as if hunting our people down and forcing them onto reservations was at one time, the patriotic thing to do. Dr. Quintard Taylor (who is black) of the University of Washington has put the whole situation in perspective when he said, “Here you have black men killing red men for the white man”. Has it been forgotten that the Buffalo Soldiers were so recently emancipated from 200 years of slavery by the white man at the time? Also, our museum has uncovered evidence that the earliest account of anyone ever claiming to have coined the phrase, ‘Buffalo Soldiers’ was by a white man. Former Texas Ranger, Ed Carnal wrote, “At Fort Richardson were stationed what we Texans called the ‘buffalo soldiers’—U.S. negro troops”. Ed Carnal died in 1921 at the age of 72. Thanks to Ed Carnal, we can put the bizarre myth to rest that our ancestors ‘honored’ those who hunted them with the name, “Buffalo Soldiers’.

As long as America fails to admit the influence American history had on men like Adolf Hitler, then history will continue to repeat itself. America must learn from history that Hitler emulated the organized ethnic cleansing and genocide found in the history of America. Today, the indigenous people of the rain forests of Brazil continue to be forced off their land and killed just as it was done in America during the time of the Buffalo Soldiers. As in Nazi Germany, there existed a culture here in America that glorified extermination. William Henry Harrison, who would later become president remarked that most frontiersmen “consider the murdering of Indians in the highest degree meritorious”. In September of 1868 the Buffalo Soldiers killed 25 Apaches and were allowed after the battle to collect scalps and souvenirs by Lieutenant Cusack. Upon their return to Fort Davis, Texas, they were observed “rigged out’ in “full Indian costume with the most fantastic head-dresses” and their “faces painted in a comical style”. How did the Buffalo Soldiers differentiate between friendly Indians and hostile? The formula was simple: “Indians who rejected reservation life were regarded as hostile”. When genocide is not condemned, it is glorified.

President Teddy Roosevelt once wrote of the Sand Creek Massacre, “…the so called Chivington or Sandy Creek Massacre, in spite of certain most objectionable details, was on the whole as righteous and beneficial a deed as ever took place on the frontier.”

Steve Melendez is the president of  the American Indian Genocide Museum and a member of the Paiute Nation of Pyramid Lake Tribe.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page




wisgriz's picture
This is a great article. The truth about the Buffalo soldiers is a long time overdue. What people don't know is that the Buffalo Soldiers were in The Dakota's as well. I spoke to a man from the Crow Creek Reservation. He mention that the Buffalo soldiers raped Dakota women while they were in the territory. That memory still reasonates with the Lakota people to this day. I understand this story is well known throughout the Western Tribes. Great work. Wisgriz
gsevalikova's picture
Excellent article. All the more reason to watch closely any more attempts to repeat the same events by the usual and new players. Surprising that a politician from America could EVER go for this again. All the same,there are moves afoot like that trade agreement being protested by the Kilcher girl in the magazine's story today. If any person doubts it,the security firm from BRITAIN was hired to guard the Embassy, and NO MARINES WERE PRESENT to help. (stevequayle.com)
soldierblue's picture
Excellent!...Glad to see mention made by others than myself of the fact that there is a American Indian Holocaustal Museum...despite what others close their eyes and speak of without comprehension...much like the bering strait theory...You, Jacqueline Baptiste, and myself had a radio interview at about the time of inception of this our museum...on public radio kpft People Of Earth show...Good to know everything continues...Good
mrizabarte's picture
Difficult subjet attended to well. The UN Convention on Prevention and Punishmen f the Crime of Genocide was made US law in 1987 by the Proxmiere Act. The current form of "ethnic cleansing" or "genocide" is being applied to our living culture by federal agencies under the name of "cultural triage." What make this genocide is that the federal agencies are doing this for the benefit of the US and the profit of the commerical institution such as gold mining corporations or commercial nuclear industry.
1nightwalker's picture
Some of us are still feeling those attempts of genocide against the Native people of this country. I am still feeling Sand Creek....and that was several generations ago. I'm glad to know that at least I can say some of my past relatives knew what freedom was...away from what we now live with. And I'm proud to know that some of family gave their all back then to protect and preserve the way of life Creator gave them to live. Nee aash !
mastincalasapa's picture
Thanks for this story. I'm Native and Jewish, and I've always noticed how differently these 2 genocides have been handled in the U.S.' collective historical memory. I agree that the problem is not (as some people argue) too much being done to remember the victims of the Shoah/Holocaust, but not enough being done to honor the memory of the millions of Indigenous people murdered here. My friends in Germany have told me that honoring the memory of the genocide there is very important in their culture. You can't call someone a "Nazi" jokingly there the way people often do here without serious social consequences. In the U.S., though, people use racist words and hate speech against Native people all the time, and we are accused of being too sensitive if we complain about it. It seems like Germans are a lot more serious about taking responsibility for their past, and doing whatever they can to apologize and make sure it never happens again, than Americans are. I know German culture is far from perfect, but I wish our society could take a page from their book and do more to own up to the genocide that went on (and in some ways is still going on) here. Good to know about the American Indian Genocide Museum in Houston - I'll have to visit sometime!
Anonymous's picture
The difference between the German and the American is that they lost the war, and American haven't.
Anonymous's picture
This article sucks... not enough information.
rkrugg's picture
Nice article, Steve. It helps remind us that by remembering the Holocaust, we don't detract from our recognition of the atrocity of genocide here in this country, but instead, can gain a deeper understanding of it. "If you leave the Jewish Holocaust Museum with an eerie feeling that the Jewish Holocaust and American history are somehow connected, you are right."