Quapaw Tribe Files Suit Against Federal Government for Alleged Land Mismanagement

Brian Daffron
4/2/13

 

The Quapaw Tribe of Oklahoma filed suit against the United States in federal court on March 25. Based on collected evidence of land and monetary account mismanagement, the case was filed as a class action lawsuit in behalf of both the approximately 4,500 member-Quapaw Tribe based in Quapaw, in the northeast corner of Oklahoma, and at least 400 individual Quapaw landowners. The tribe is seeking $175 million in damages going back to at least the 1890s.

The original area of the Quapaw Reservation in Oklahoma was due to removal from present-day Arkansas through the 1830s. According to a press release issued by the Quapaw Tribe, the Quapaw lands of Oklahoma “was the site of one of the richest discoveries of lead and zinc ever made in the United States.” However, according to the press release, the results of mining negligence destroyed Quapaw tribal lands, encompassing these lands within the Tar Creek Superfund site.

A case study of Tar Creek published on the University of Michigan website states that Quapaw is one of the five mining towns in which residents have been exposed to high levels of lead, zinc, cadmium and other heavy metals from 1891 to 1970. As of March 2013, Tar Creek is still under Remedial Action status with the Environmental Protection Agency.

“It was a very close relationship at the time,” Quapaw Chairman John Berrey said to Indian Country Today Media Network about the ties between the federal government and the mining companies. “The negotiation for the amount and the bonding for the cleanup was all managed by the Department of the Interior. If you go up there today, you can see that the bonding and the enforcement of the cleanup was never done.”

The investigation for the lawsuit has been part of a 10-year process, including four years of research in the national archives. In 2005, the Quapaw Tribe settled a lawsuit with the United States based on the accounting contract originally managed by the DOI. A result of this settlement was the expanded investigation of other federal documents pertaining to the Quapaw. Berrey said that this process also included research of state archives, universities and museums, with the tribe gathering nearly 1 million digitized pages “that tell the story of the management at Quapaw.”

The Quapaw release also states that the Department of the Interior agreed to “mediate the claims of the tribe as its members” as part of the original 2005 settlement. However, the Quapaw Tribe claims that the Justice Department intervened and told them to file a lawsuit instead. When this occurred, the Quapaw Tribe went through Congress to gain support through congressional reference, authorizing the Quapaw Tribe to file through the U.S. Court of Federal Claims with H.R. 5862.

The Quapaw Tribe’s press release cites a quote from the resolution’s primary sponsor, Congressman and Chickasaw Nation tribal member Tom Cole, R-Okla. The statement said “[d]espite a 10-year legal process during which the tribe fulfilled every step of its agreement with the government, the Justice Department failed to follow through, leaving this important issue unresolved.”

Other supporters of the resolution include Representatives Lamar Smith, R-Texas, Zoe Lofgren, D-Calif., and former U.S. Representative Dan Boren, D-Okla.

With the Cobell case making more recent headlines, ICTMN asked Chairman Berrey the differences between Cobell and the Quapaw’s federal lawsuit. According to Berrey, the Quapaw’s lawsuit deals not only with the mismanagement of individual monies but also with specific land resource mismanagement and specific tribal claims.

“Some of it’s a tribal claim; part of it is individual claims,” said Berrey. “Cobell was mostly an accounting claim against the Individual Indian Monies account management. For years, the Quapaw Tribe and some other people always complained that the real problem was in the resource management.”

Berrey also said that the Quapaw Tribe asked its members to “opt out of the resource management claim in Cobell” but to still receive their IIM account claim. Additionally, Berrey made the distinction of the Quapaw’s case being within the U.S. Court of Federal Claims instead of U.S. District Court, as was the case with Cobell.

“It’s more about the management of the asset or the resource itself,” said Berrey. “The tribal claim also includes our tribal account.”

ICTMN asked the Bureau of Indian Affairs to comment on the Quapaw Tribe’s filing. Nedra Darling, spokeswoman for the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Indian Affairs, stated in an e-mailed reply that “[t]he Department of the Interior’s policy is not to report on matters that are currently in litigation.”

When asked how the Quapaw Tribe’s lawsuit will help Native people as a whole, Berrey said it gives the Quapaw an opportunity to share their story.

“We have actual, factual evidence and a unique story,” said Berrey. “At Quapaw, we think, it is one of the most heinous, illegal managements that took place in Indian country. It’s a horrible story; it’s a sad story. We’re really excited that we get to bring our story to the courts.”

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

POST A COMMENT

Comments

Anonymous's picture
Anonymous
Submitted by Anonymous on
John Berrey is amoral. He does not live a Native American life. He is nothing but a capitalist asshole lining his pockets with casino money.

エアジョーダン 4's picture
エアジョーダン 4
Submitted by エアジョーダン 4 on
陣痛から産声まで3日かかった難産だった。Q.会員コースによってサービス内容は異なりますか?016円(税込)当店通常価格3,jp※土日祝祭日はお休みをいただきます。26 松本拓也 GK 湘南 完全移籍 12.ヘール?「スタンレーがユースチームの全てで構築したあらゆることを、上手く繋げていくことが我々のタスクだ。

エアジョーダン 2013's picture
エアジョーダン 2013
Submitted by エアジョーダン 2013 on
regulators say, forcing health-care providers to offer sign language interpreters and other services for the hearing-impaired They have negotiated settlements on behalf of HIV patients improperly denied treatment According to a copy of the settlement the parents alleged that Dominion officials failed to provide them appropriate accommodations such as a sign language translator while their son was being treated at the hospital in late 2010 At one point according to the settlement US attorneys found that a sign language interpreter did not show up at a family meeting and hospital officials relied on the man being treated to facilitate communication with his parents He returned to Kabul with no public sign of progress.The accusations by Afghan officials came just days after Afghan President Hamid and met with its new prime minister," Yet upon the direction of the president new IRS acting Commissioner Daniel Werfel ordered a 30-day review upon which Werfel claimed the agency found no "" How could a 30-day review by a new official credibly clear an entire agency after a year-long independent had just found significant unanswered questionsWorking with the IRS congressional Democrats then tried to sell Americans on a new rationale that this was "" by trying and falsely equating routine scrutiny of progressive groups to tea party applications The inspector general however stood his ground countering that the facts still support the conclusion that tea party groups were systematically scrutinized at a level above and beyond other applicants During the 27 months during which the IRS did not approve one application for tax-exempt status from a tea party group the agency approved "perhaps dozens of applications from similar liberal and progressive groups" Front-line IRS workers were not instructed to route progressive organizations to a special coordinator; these groups applications were simply processed through the general inventoryMeanwhile the White House has vacillated between indifference and acknowledgment of inappropriate IRS behavior Consider this: On the same day President Obama bemoaned the "" plaguing his administration his chief spokesman Jay Carney allowed that "" Which is it"Lets just take the IRS scandal The fact is its far different than what you said" CarneyThe American people demand and deserve accountability from their government not to live in fear of being subject to an audit or other extra scrutiny for reasons unrelated to the content of their filing So far the IRS and this administration have provided no assurances that oversight and accountability is in place to prevent such abuses from happening again The administrations own partisan its evolving and inconsistent explanations and the IRSs own unwillingness to fulfill the presidents promises of cooperation with our investigation have fueled skepticism about how dedicated they are to holding the responsible parties accountable We are committed to a thorough and fair investigation Our committees are working to find out how this happened and how we can prevent any taxpayer from being targeted The American people deserve to know that they have a government that works for them not against them The White House and the IRS should fully cooperate It is the only way Americans can regain lost trust in this administration .But in 2008, The study found that EAB's effects can be linked to more than 21, moderate temperature and provide opportunities for physical activity; trees are psychologically soothing and act as buffers for stress; a walk through the woods reduces heart rates and lowers cortisol levels; children living on tree-lined streets are less likely to have asthma. along with several lamp-post flags of Flacco throughout downtown Denver.

iphone4 ケース's picture
iphone4 ケース
Submitted by iphone4 ケース on
too horrifying to believe, it is still one of the world’s most rigidly controlled." she says, for all I know.” to compromise in general and compromise with Obama in particular2. . And we thank the president for his efforts in those regards. (Applause.” the groups wrote. EST.
5