Header

Greed, Corruption and Indian Country's New Welfare States

Leland McGee
6/27/13

Indian country’s pecuniary advancements created by Indian gaming are well documented. Many tribes have taken full advantage of expanding and diversifying business ventures that now represent a sustainable economic base far greater than their initial casino enterprise. Such planning and financial discipline is commendable. Strong tribal leadership and the willingness to do what is in the best interest of the citizenry of those governments is usually the common thread of success for those tribes. Many times, however, decisions made by tribal councils to obtain such successful economic diversity come at a political price: risking their leadership positions by standing up to their constituents and saying no to either initiating per capita payments, or increasing them beyond sensible levels.

Unfortunately, many tribes today have lost that astute fiscal resolve. In its stead, per capita has become something so adverse amongst so many of our people that it now serves to hinder, disrupt and in some instances, even dismantle tribal governments. Disenrollment, political turmoil, government breakdowns, corruption, financial dependency and absolute greed has become the new “norm” for too many gaming tribes. I’ve witnessed more times than I care to admit, general councils literally holding tribal councils political hostage over per capita distributions. Chants of: “either pay us more per capita, or we’ll vote you out and replace you with someone who will” has become commonplace within many tribal communities. Sound familiar?

The truth of the matter is that per capita payments do little to improve our tribal communities, much less peoples’ lives. Yes, we have a sovereign right to establish per capita for our citizens, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s “the right thing to do.” Some of our most formidable leaders during the early years of Indian gaming argued against per capita. They understood that the net gaming profits from our casino operations were the financial gifts born from the struggles to evolve and develop this industry. Gaming was viewed as an important tool to address generational socio-economic disparity throughout Indian country. Gaming revenues were our way of lessening our dependency on federal funding sources, as well as our opportunity to strengthen and improve tribal government operations, which is a true exercise in sovereignty.

Many tribal governments realized that creating a system of per capita payouts to tribal citizens established nothing short of a tribally funded “welfare state.” Tribes that opposed and rejected per capita payments to their citizens early on were, by and large, the ones setting the standard for quality of life improvements within their communities. As a tribal citizen, enjoying this new influx of casino revenue meant that your basic needs in life were provided for, so long as you earned and/or qualified for such assistance. This included housing, education, health care, child care, elder assistance, business start-up assistance and a slew of other programs and services that casino revenues provided.

Today’s trend though seems to be growing more and more negative in regards to per capita outlays. We have families pitted against families fighting over who is and who is not a rightful citizen of their tribal government. Issues that were never in dispute before per capita payments were declared, now grow in volume and intensity. Disenrollment was extremely rare and when exercised, was for actual cause (no Indian blood quantum, dual enrollment, et cetera), not because of greed and corruption over per capita outlays. Such actions only serve to kill our native culture. We lose respect, credibility and support throughout the United States, especially within the federal government, and look absolutely ridiculous in the eyes of the world. A proud people we are not when we allow an infiltration of bad acts and bad actors to operate and control tribal governments, spurred on by overwhelming dictate from tribal citizens demanding more and more “free” money from their tribes.

So, what can be done to reverse this trend? Maybe we begin by nurturing and empowering stronger leadership within our tribal governments. Tribal councils willing to stand in unison against per capita payments, or increases thereto, is a good starting point. Regaining control of tribal finances and putting those dollars to work in other areas are also key goals. Tribes that utilize gaming proceeds to diversify economic portfolios, generate new business ventures, create jobs and grow tribal wealth beyond casino operations, better control per capita greed. Also, lest not forget that in most states, our monopoly over casino-style gaming enterprises is a very fragile one. At any time we can see changes to state gaming laws that allow expansion of casino-style gaming to non-Indian entities in and around population centers, as a way of increasing state tax revenues and thereby devastating a large percentage of Indian gaming as we know it.

Many of us have and will continue to dedicate our lives to prevent such circumstances from occurring. However, we need to do a much better job of perpetuating positive views and opinions in the public domain on how we utilize our gaming revenues. It’s a lot easier arguing protectionism of Indian gaming’s status quo in states around the country struggling to raise more revenues, if we are not constantly lambasted in the press over tribal infighting based on nothing more than greed. Better educating our people as to the pitfalls of per capita dependency is also critical. It’s a tough challenge for any tribal council to face, but in the end such efforts may save a tribal government and the communities it serves. Our fights to secure Indian gaming was to improve government operations, tribal business ventures and overall quality of life for our citizens; not to politically cannibalize ourselves through acts of voracity, corruption and the spread of destructive per capita dependency among our own people.

Leland McGee, a citizen of the Cherokee Nation, is a principal of the Sequoyah Group, LLC, a native-owned national Indian economic, energy and gaming development consulting firm. He has served in Indian Affairs under both Clinton and Bush Administrations, served under the National Congress of American Indians, directed government affairs for a national Indian law firm, and has served as executive director and tribal administrator for federally recognized tribal governments.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

7

POST A COMMENT

Comments

Anonymous's picture
What a novel idea. "Per capita distributions from tribal funds to be used for ordinary living expenses should also be rigorously restricted." Merriam Report 1928
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
That's your personal wrong opinion! And your a white BIA and IRA guy, that don't know sh...t! Those per caps belong to the authentic SOVEREIGN traditional governments and indigenous nationhood's and their individual's! It was never the BIA or IRA monies or revenues, its the Peoples, Traditional Peoples revenues! The corruption is the IRA and BIA gatekeepers of modern day ethnic cleansing genocide got their hands on the money that belongs to the PEOPLE, AND ITS NOBODYS BUSINESS, EXSPEACEALLY, IRA AND BIA PHONY OPPRESSIVE FEDERAL GATEKEEPERS OF COLONIAL DOMIANTION OF US AND COLONIZAL EXPANSIONISM ON TRADTIONAL TERRITORIAL TREATY LANDS, ONLY TO STEAL MORE RESOURCES AND SOVERIEGN RED HOMELANDS! It's NOT BIA OR IRA BUSINESS WHAT ANY INDIVIUAL AUTHETNIC SOVEREIGN TRATIONALIST FIRST NATION NATIONALIST DOES WITH HER OR HIS MONEY! QUIT GOING AROUND TELLING EVERYONE YOUR INDIAN! BULL, WHITE MAN!!!! THE TRUE IS THE LAST PEOPLES YOU WANT TO HANDLE THE MONEY OF ALL FIRST NATIONS CASINO'S ARE BIA AND IRA MURDERERS, THEIVES, LANDSQUTTERS, LIAR'S, DRUNKS, DRUG ADDICTICS, WIFE BEATER'S, WHITE MANS INDIANS AND SUPPORTER MURDERERS OF OUR PEOPLE AND DIVINE SOVERIEGN HOMELANDS AND RED INDIGENOUS NATIONHOOD'S, GIVEN TO US BY CREATOR OF ALL LIFE!!!! NOT BY YOU BIA JOURNALIST!
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Per capita, has done more damage than good, in some reservations that I have seen. In general, the new monies from Indian Gaming. What I have witnessed is it literally takes the incentive away from the reservation Indians to leave and better themselves. Why go get and education when you get a free new home, per capita, rides to the diabetes clinic and the salt, sugar and fat store is just down the road. Things most people work and aspire to be and have are now given or even expected. In the near future, when gaming becomes widespread and exclusive, the money well will dry up and what will they have left?
Anonymous
Two Bears Growling's picture
Well said brother of the people! It is sickening at the disease called GREED & it's relatives corruption, ego & cousin; perceived power. It has crept in our communities & is destroying FAR more than it helps. As you say, it promotes a welfare mentality. What it doesn't do is teach people financial responsibility. I get so sick of seeing on some reservations nice houses paid for by the tribes because of insane profits from the casinos, having holes in their siding, boarded up &/or broken windows & wrecked late-model vehicles in the yards. Someone failed to teach respectability & decent behavior to their offspring while at home. Money can never buy good common sense nor can it buy someone respectability within their families, clans or tribes. It cannot buy you a good name when you have brought shame to yourself, your family, your clan or your tribe. Much wealth destroys more people than it ever helped. I have seen good & decent folks destroyed by it & become someone others no longer even know. It poisons their spirit. It causes them to lose their morals & do things they never would have even considered BEFORE they acquired a good deal of wealth &/or power. Wealth, combined with power, bad company, booze, drugs & egos, is many a person's destruction.
Two Bears Growling
dpwiese's picture
Along with disenrollment some tribes have refused services and funding to off reservation members. According to the latest 2010 U.S. Census, over 78% of all Indian people live off reservation. They do not even need to disenroll them.
dpwiese
Rose Villa's picture
As enrolled Blackfeet I see intense corruption within tribal government. Our infrastructure is practically nonexistant. Unemployment is scandalously high. Mortality rates from alcoholism is the highest in the globe. Nothing changes within tribal leadership. The leaders are so inept, unqualified to develop financial independance, they busy stealing what they can during their terms, & have no educational backgrounds to do otherwise! Health conditions are the same as the third world on our reservation. Per capita payments or let the council steal & mismanage financial systems till the sources are expended is about the gist of our conditions.
Rose Villa
Anonymous's picture
All on the same page, again reading the wrong book. Infraspect's Indigenous Identity Theft & fraud, technical brief, refutes and redirects attention to the collectivism, e.g. non-profit/profit new breed of Indian corporations, and their respective "partners" legally plundering the last natural assets, by consolidating corporate (PGO) ownership and individual property in the hands of new Indian country "collaborators," especially the lawyers, judges and their special beneficiaries.
Anonymous