Header

The Difference Between Being a Slut & a Racist: Pochahottie Hottentot

Ruth Hopkins
10/26/13

Ahh, yes. Halloween is just around the corner. Time for pumpkin carving, Trick-Or-Treating, and women dressed like two-dollar hookers wearing headdresses. What better way to celebrate the ancient pagan feast of Samhain, where the spirits of the dead roam free, than to wear slutty costumes that reduce people of other races to stereotypical hypersexualized caricatures. After all, why keep the embarrassment and denigration all to yourself?

Wait…what?

Lindsay Lohan said it best in Mean Girls: “Halloween is the one night a year when girls can dress like a total slut and no other girls can say anything.”

Say what you will about whether using Halloween as an excuse to advertise your goodies is right or wrong, but I can assure you of one thing: dressing as a sexy pirate, a hot nurse or even a slutty pizza slice, is not the same thing as dressing up as a sexy Indian princess, cheeky Cherokee or naughty Navajo. They aren’t just examples of having a little fun with patriarchy (and figuratively slapping Susan B. Anthony and your grandmother in the face simultaneously). It’s racist.

Native Americans are not costumes, we’re human beings. The traditional clothing we wear is called regalia, and looks nothing like the faux 1950’s Hollywood shit that pop culture pawns off on consumers as “Indian.” All Native American people are not the same. There are 566 federally recognized Native American Tribes in the United States. Each possesses its own distinct culture, language, heritage, and land base. Furthermore, we don’t take kindly to non-Natives debasing our sacred objects. The war bonnet, for example, is reserved for Native American warriors and chiefs who’ve fought bravely for their people. Each feather in a war bonnet symbolizes a single act of courage in the face of death and destruction- and no, fielding crowds of sweaty, irritable shoppers to buy a fake headdress at Spirit Halloween doesn’t count. War bonnets are more akin to Purple Hearts.

As a Native American, I can’t tell you what an absolute pain it is to traverse through aisles of costumes this time of year, especially with children in tow. Mommy doesn’t like explaining why Party City is selling a “Cheeky Cherokee” teen costume that promises to send its wearers “heading for the woods,” or why Spirit Halloween is displaying a “Naughty Navajo” mini dress that will have women “sending out smoke signals.”  

Like any decent parent, I try to teach my daughter to carry herself with pride and dignity. These racist costumes, that specifically target her purely because of her race, send her the message that Native American women are viewed as sex objects. It makes her sad and angry. She knows those costumes are not who we as Native women are, and that we should not be depicted that way. Statistically, a shocking one in three Native American women will be sexually assaulted in her lifetime. Encouraging the public to view Native American women as disposable sex toys is more than a grave insult, it’s irresponsible and negligent.

Speaking of negligent, Cherokee and Navajo are the names of sovereign tribal nations. There could be trademarks involved. Last year, the Navajo Nation filed a lawsuit against Urban Outfitters for just that, and violations against the federal Indian Arts and Crafts Act, after the tribe discovered they were selling their now infamous “Navajo” hipster panty and flask. Party City, Spirit Halloween, and anyone else who uses the names of tribes to sell their wares without the tribe’s permission is hereby put on notice. You could be engaging in illegal activity.

Who makes these costumes anyway? Party City mentions online that its products are manufactured “both in the United States and overseas.” I shudder to think that an Indigenous child in some far off land is being made to slave over a costume used to appropriate Indigenous peoples in this country.

The other day, a clueless non-Native miscreant told me that “Native women are sexy,” and that’s why non-Native women try to emulate them. Excuse me if I’m not flattered, and here, hold my purse while I kick him in the nuts. He did have a point though, in that white men have fetishized and eroticized women of other races and ethnicities throughout history, leading white women to imitate those features. One such case is that of Sarah Baartman, an African tribeswoman and former slave who was exhibited in freak show attractions in Europe in the early 1800s. Sarah was kind, intelligent, and spoke several languages, but that’s not what she was known for. She was displayed so white men could gawk at her large buttocks and elongated vaginal labia. Seen purely as an object of sexual gratification, Sarah was called the Hottentot Venus. The popularity of Sarah’s sizeable posterior is believed to be the chief inspiration behind the bustles that became so fashionable in Europe soon after her arrival.

Racism and misogyny are interwoven. The hypersexualization of Native women through slutty red face costumes is a prime example of that. Native women are not your sexual playthings, nor should we be mocked and marginalized because of our race. So yeah, go be a sexy ghost, but leave my people out of it.

Ruth Hopkins (Sisseton-Wahpeton, Mdewakanton, Hunkpapa) is a writer, blogger, administrator, and the Chief Judge of the Spirit Lake Nation. She's a columnist for Indian Country Today Media Network, a founding writer for Lastrealindians.com, and a contributor to Truthout.org, Jezebel.com, Counterpunch.org, and Racialicious.com. Her work has been featured in dozens of other places online and in print. She's also a published horror author.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

31

POST A COMMENT

Comments

Anonymous's picture
Great piece. It's really sad that many non-Natives are very ignorant of their behavior. Perhaps this can bring some information and education.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
great writing. refreshingly poignant. or whatever sounds good to say, I like your style.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
It's especially sad that most Native women are so modest only to have to face this type of stereotyping in stores. These types of costumes (and they ARE costumes, not regalia) are demeaning to Native Americans and have no business being sold in the U.S. You can't buy a costume of an African slave or a Mexican gardner, why can you buy an "Indian" costume? Hopefully the days of these ridiculous costumes and the NFL Redskins will soon be over.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Thank you, Ms. Hopkins!
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Well, it'd be my great great grandmother and Susan B. Anthony, but close enough. I frankly find such costumes no more or less offensive than naughty nurse or drunken pilgrim. They're costumes. Silly. Costumes. Of all the things I lose sleep and/or get worked up over, this one isn't making the list.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
"white men have fetishized and eroticized women of other races and ethnicities throughout history, leading white women to imitate those features." Very true, but it's more accurate to say that men in general do this, not just white men. Great article.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Take a deep breath---exhale slowly---and get a friggin grip on life! You won't be happy till you're back in the TeePee.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
I think we should be careful not endorse sexism with the use of words like whore/slut thereby endorsing the virgin/whore dichotomy. There is definitely a hypersexualized caricature of Native women which further marginalizes the women in our communities but how a woman dresses should not be generalized to being a whore/slut. These terms are part of rape culture and should not be part of the deconstruction of racist/sexist behavior.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
#Amen
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Thank You for the article. Oh my yes, it is very sad to see Native Costumes that are so 'cheap'. Also is is a disgrace for the young girls of America to wear such slutty outfits that have been promoted by the main-stream media as 'good.' i.e.; ALL the Disney outfits, of which all are of poor taste, (not just Pocohantes) . Teaching our children to have native pride without feeling better than any other human should be our goal. However, we must show our pride without the anger and hatred that so many young natives have. I understand, there is good reason to be angry, but Unity should be our goal. Teach your little girls the proper attire, share our rich and diverse heritage. Do this in an honorable way. Anyway, I feel Halloween is a corporate hoax, aimed to funnel our monies to the big pockets of huge companies like; Hallmark, Mars, Hershey, and the Chinese costume makers. Thank You, Ruth for your sharing your viewpoint in your poignant way. :)
Anonymous

Pages