‘Big-Nosed Heads on Jerseys’: Native Mascots Harm Native Youth Every Day

Vincent Schilling
8/1/14

Last week the Center for American Progress released a report highlighting the impact of Native mascots and team names on American Indian and Alaska Native youth and proposed key steps that federal, state, and local governments can take to address these effects.

In addition to releasing the report entitled “Missing the Point, The Real Impact of Native Mascots and Team Names on American Indian and Alaska Native Youth,” the CAP held a press conference with key tribal representatives and Native youth to include Erik Stegman, Associate Director of Half in Ten at the Center for American Progress and 15 year old Dahkota Brown to discuss the impacts of Native Mascots and team names.

RELATED: Put Native Youth Back in Mascots Debate

In a release Stegman discussed the need for the public to know the impact of Native mascots outlined in the report and discussed at the press conference.

“It’s time to address the real issues in the debate about derogatory nicknames and mascots, and local, state, and federal education agencies have a role to play,” said Stegman. “Racist representations in schools undermine the understanding of Native people, contribute to hostile learning environments, and make a challenging situation worse for Native students who live in communities where poverty is at nearly double the national rate, high school graduation rates are some of the lowest in the country, and extreme health disparities persist.”

In the report, written by Stegman and Victoria Philips, four key steps are outlined in terms of steps government agencies, nonprofit organizations and grant making bodies can make to improve the current climate of public non-awareness to offensive mascots.

The federal government should take action to ensure civil rights protections.

The U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights should use its full authority to enforce civil rights protections for American Indian and Alaska Native students and promote a safe and welcoming learning environment.

State governments should hold local institutions accountable.

State-level boards of education and education agencies should identify schools in their state with American Indian and Alaska Native representations, examine their impact, and develop recommendations to remove harmful representations.

Nonprofit organizations should support students who take legal action. 

Nonprofit legal assistance organizations and law school clinics should develop programs to support American Indian and Alaska Native students who want to file complaints.

Grant-making bodies should continue research on student impacts.

The federal government and foundation community should identify and fund new research on the impact of derogatory American Indian and Alaska Native representations in schools.

After the press conference, Stegman and 15-year-old Dahkota Brown (a 2013 Champion for Change) told ICTMN their thoughts about the success of the event and how efforts to foster awareness could be implemented.

RELATED: Champion for Change Chosen for Helping Fellow Native Students

Stegman said that though he is glad to see awareness to this issue gaining traction every day, there still is room to grow at a national level.

“Too much of the national debate about mascots has been missing the point, because this really is an issue that harms Native students every day,” he said. In schools across the country, K-12 and post-secondary, Native students have to see their culture boiled down to a logo or team name. Research shows that these representations lead to lower self-esteem for Native youth, misunderstandings of Native people by non-Native people, and contributes to an unwelcome and often times hostile learning environment.”

Stegman also applauded Brown’s sharing at the conference. “Dahkota’s remarks helped put a real Native voice to this issue. Too much of this debate has centered on non-Native people talking to other non-Native people about what they think these mascots and team names mean. Dahkota spoke from the heart as a Native high school student and football player, and shared an important personal story that represents what Native youth face across the country.”

Brown says the event, was a complete success. “The event had a great turn out with a packed room. I think people were excited or curious to hear about the real effects of this issue from not only a youth like myself, but also from tribal leaders like Jacqueline Pata and Mark Macarro. An amazing amount of knowledge about the issue and its harmful effects was spread. There were knowledgeable speakers for the panel discussion and Erik Stegman did a great job moderating. Congresswoman Betty McCollum also had some great remarks and is a great advocate for Indian country.”

Pages

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

POST A COMMENT

Comments

chahta ohoyo's picture
chahta ohoyo
Submitted by chahta ohoyo on
halito! you are kidding, right....you expect the same govt who condones cature-ization of every other race on and off this planet to actually, at ANY point in the near future, step in and stop it being done to us??? it is a 'human' failing to poke fun at anything/anyone NOT you...you cant legislate morality...

chahta ohoyo's picture
chahta ohoyo
Submitted by chahta ohoyo on
edit: should have been 'caricaturization'....my computer does stupid things when its mad...*(

Michael Madrid's picture
Michael Madrid
Submitted by Michael Madrid on
SARCASM ON/ Don't YOU PEOPLE know you're being honored? Don't you know that the original owner of the Redskins was an Indian? Don't you know that Chief Wahoo represents the very best things in sports (no, not rape, drugs and spouse abuse - fair play, good sportsmanship and honesty). Don't you Indians have more important things to worry about? Besides, you're taking it all out of context - the original meaning was blah, blah, blah . . . . /SARCASM OFF TO CHAHTA OHOYO: You're right, it's impossible to legislate morality or even civility, but measures to eradicate these images and their corporate sponsorship is a great leap forward! You don't see "Little Black Sambo" or the "Frito Bandito" on television anymore. What confuses me is why are Native Americans okay to caricaturize, but try doing it with ANY OTHER GROUP and Americans would scream!
3