Glenn Shepard
Left, Xero, a Chitonahua woman in Peru shortly after her group was forcibly contacted by loggers after fleeing violence from loggers in Brazil in 1996. Right, A young Chitonahua man who lost one eye to a shotgun blast by Brazilian loggers; his brother was shot in the leg by Peruvian loggers in 1996.

Banana Diplomacy: Making First Contact With Uncontacted Tribe in Amazon

Felipe Milanez and Glenn Shepard

They were separated only by the narrow course of the Envira river. From a distance of a few meters they tried to speak to each other. As the video clip recently released by Funai shows below, Fernando Ashaninka entered the water as two Xatanawa mirrored his motions from the opposite bank. One Xatanawa man remained behind with a gun (apparently captured from an unfortunate logger) in case of an attack. After unsuccessful attempts at spoken communication they turned to gestures and eventually Fernando gave them bananas. The Xatanawa then follow the Ashaninka and FUNAI team to the village and ask for clothing. Watching the video, one only hopes that the used clothes the Xatanawa received aren’t contaminated with flu virus or other harmful diseases. The speaker on the video announces that this was the "first contact" with the Xatanawa people. But there had been several previous interactions between the Xatanawa and the Ashaninka community of Simpatia.

FUNAI’s recent video

The seven Xatanawa survivors of the recent massacre who reached out to Simpatia included five men and two women, in addition to some 40 to 100 that stayed behind in the forest. They first appeared on June 10, to take iron goods, clothes and food. An Ashaninka man, Raimundinho, initially considered this an act of “thievery,” but the village leader “Carijó” quickly informed FUNAI and organized and informed the village to avoid violent confrontations. Rather than thieves, they were more like diplomats, coming on an urgent peace-making mission.

RELATED: Murderous Drug Traffickers Force Isolated Group in Amazon to Make Contact

Members of the same group had already made enigmatic appearances at other Ashaninka and Kulina villages along the Envira River, according to the Indigenous Missionary Council (CIMI). In March of 2014, Renato Santana from CIMI told journalist Scott Wallace, “Women are afraid to go into the forest to tend their gardens for fear of abduction.” CIMI released additional aerial photographs of the group in April and demanded that FUNAI act to protect their territory. The FUNAI post at Xinane, which had been established as an advanced base to handle this situation, has been closed since it was attacked by drug traffickers in 2011.

After their dramatic, brief appearance at Simpatia on June 10, FUNAI began preparing for an eminent contact, which came on June 27 with an initial peaceful encounter followed by additional visits on June 29 and 30, culminating in a longer meeting on July 4, when the Xatanawa emissaries remained for several hours at Simpatia before returning to the forest.

Since 1987, with the creation of FUNAI’s Department of Isolated Indians, the official policy in Brazil has been “no contact unless necessary,” with major investments made in identification, monitoring and territorial protection. In 1988, the veteran FUNAI employee José Carlos Meirelles established the base on the Xinane River, at its confluence with the Envira, since it was, in his words, “Equidistant in location between various groups living in isolation, and the Ashaninka community, and also a strategic place to control the territory through river access. Because there on the upper Envira, as we first suspected, and have now confirmed, is the territory of several indigenous populations who refuse contact.”


You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



Catriona Heather
Catriona Heather
Submitted by Catriona Heather on
Why are the scum of the earth loggers and traffickers allowed to get away with all that they do? I can't comprehend it. They need to control these illegal monsters - I would go back to the Amazon and fight them myself if someone showed me where to go and how to get there! They need to be stopped! Brasil trains its army in the Amazon, they could easily place them where these traffickers and loggers are, and actually make a difference! Infuriating!