House Majority Leader Eric Cantor

House Republican VAWA Bill Offers Strong Tribal Protections; Will Cantor Accept?

Rob Capriccioso
2/22/13

 

Republican House members Tom Cole (Okla.) and Darrell Issa (Calif.) on February 20 issued new Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) legislation that includes stronger tribal jurisdictional provisions than a similar bill they released last year.

Their bill, titled the Violence Against Indian Women Act of 2013, would give tribes criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians who commit domestic violence against Indian woman and families on tribal lands. That means tribal courts would have the authority to prosecute non-Indians accused of abusing their partners on tribal lands, which is a major ongoing problem, according to federal and tribal statistics.

Jocelyn Rogers, a spokeswoman for Cole, explained that the new bill would authorize, rather than just grant, tribes such authority, and it includes language that offers stricter rules for having cases removed from tribal courts to district courts. That is, defendants must be able to prove by “clear and convincing evidence” that a right guaranteed them under the Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 has been violated, and that the tribal court has failed to adequately remedy the violation.

“The changes are important because they enhance [tribal] sovereignty and bring the removal standard in line with current practice,” Rogers said.

The overall legislation is similar to a bill offered by Cole and Issa in December 2012 when they tried to get House leadership to agree with VAWA tribal provisions that tribal leaders could also support. But that effort stalled amid questions about constitutionality, and there were some major concerns expressed by tribal leaders about the bill of last year—namely involving tribal authority and the removal process.

This year’s version accounts for those tribal concerns, said Ryan Dreveskracht, an Indian affairs lawyer with Galanda Broadman. He said the bill includes “[a]ll of the changes that we advocated for,” a recognition of inherent tribal authority among them.

“Getting the ‘clear and convincing’ evidence standard in there was a huge win for Indian country,” Dreveskracht added.

The issue now becomes whether the House Republican leadership will take up the tribal bill, or continue to muddy the waters with constitutional questions, as some GOP House members did during last year’s debate and as some Republican Senate members have been doing this year.

Dreveskracht, for one, sees this as a possibility: “On the downside, I've heard through the grapevine that [House Majority Leader Eric] Cantor will be pushing for a Cornyn type bill instead of Cole/Issa—which would be a huge step backward.”

Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) voted for the Senate version of VAWA that included tribal protections in early February, saying it was a bill that could do so much good in the battle for victims' rights—but he issued a caveat when it came to the rights of tribal victims: “Unfortunately the bill that passed today would take away fundamental constitutional rights from certain citizens in order to satisfy the unconstitutional demands of a few,” he said in a statement. “I hope this will be corrected in the House.” The gist is he wants the tribal provisions removed in the House.

Cantor’s office has not yet responded to requests for comment on whether he supports the new Cole/Issa bill, which has six other Republican co-sponsors. He has said that he plans to bring up a House VAWA bill soon.

Tribal advocates are pushing for Cantor to incorporate the Cole/Issa language. It will be a tough hill to climb, most admit, especially given recent comments from Republican senators who seem to be purposely signaling misguided information to their House allies.

Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), for instance, said at a recent town hall meeting that he doesn’t believe that tribal courts are able to offer a fair trial to non-Indians because he believes their juries would be made up of all Indians.

But critics of Grassley have pointed out that almost half of current reservation dwellers are non-Indians, so tribal jury pools reflect that reality. Plus, the Senate VAWA tribal provisions apply only to individuals who live on a reservation and have formed a relationship with Indian families.

At the same time, Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) is getting some heat from Indian country for his anti-tribal VAWA vote. Considering that he is the vice-chair of the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, many Indians were disappointed by his anti-tribal action.

Barrasso’s spokeswoman, Emily Lawrimore, responded to Indian Country Today Media Network’s questions about his vote, saying, “As a doctor, Sen. Barrasso is very concerned about the problem of domestic violence in Indian country and supports measures that protect women and children. He voted against the recent VAWA bill because it contains provisions that would likely be ruled unconstitutional by the courts. A Supreme Court ruling against this provision could be damaging to tribal authority and have irreversible consequences.”

It’s a response that Dreveskracht finds to be a “weak position” since the U.S. Supreme Court has already ruled that tribes have the inherent power to prosecute non-Indians.

The Supreme Court ruled in United States v. Lara (2004) that this is a valid and constitutional exercise of tribal authority,” Dreveskracht said. “Of course, there is always the chance that the court will overrule Lara and change the state of the law, but to say that a law is currently unconstitutional because of something that the court might do in the future is nonsensical.”

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

POST A COMMENT

Comments

Tom Burtnett's picture
Tom Burtnett
Submitted by Tom Burtnett on
I wouldn't be so sure about praising this section coming from Cole and Issa!!! I don't think you can trust either of them. I wouldn't fall for it so soon!

Lucille Delegge-Perez's picture
Lucille Delegge...
Submitted by Lucille Delegge... on
Pass Vawa as if any of theses men have no mother,sisters,granmothers,aunts,Where is the compassion,or do you just want to continue to promote cont. violence against he very people who bring forth your sons,

running deer-chukchansi indian california's picture
running deer-ch...
Submitted by running deer-ch... on
ditto u said it these Government officials are not to be trusted as i have seen it personnally the corrupt tribal councils decisions in cases of domestic violence against a spouse whether it be a tribal member or not has no ! They still choose not help there people when the truth is slapping them in the face! They fail to protect there people and will continue to failed time and time again and the rights of the poor tribal victim whether it be a woman or man, adult or child holds no type of moral creedance to them. As long as they are continuing to get there pockets padded with corrupt casino monies that they (Corrupt Tribal Leaders and Casino Administration and Corrupted Law Enforcement taking corrupt casino money for their own gain) are not sharing with the people who orginally helped them get all those casino machines and government grants monies because they were part of the tribe and are no longer part of . And those grants that were orginally were given to build up the tribes educationally, on all areas of: mental health, Where are the Social Programs they are suppose to have been providing for those victims of any volience, keeping good health, living habitates, senior health are and have been through all down the drain because of greed and mainly because of the one sided third world government thinking of these leaders who are bullying their power down the throats of the meek, helpless, uneducated, eldely that are afraid to speak out and raise up. To shout out a actual WAR CRY FOR HELP and speak because they are afraid they will be disenrolled banned and disinherited of their land and benefits! While these people like Reggie Lewis, Nancy Ayala, the Ramirez's, Chance Alberta use our tribes money to bribe people for votes and block tribal members votes for standing up for a newly elected counsel swore in to enforce these types of things from happening at our rancheria anymore! They were not even given a chance to correct the wrong done to the disenrolled members and open up the roll for new tribal members that were actually left off because of past differences in families. Some of the MAIN Elders of the tribe were not given the oppurtunity for even a chance at getting on the membership. Yeah I am Mad at the Third Wrld Government Mentality that the Government officals and the Corrupt Tribal Leaders have put upon there people. GROWN some BALLS GUYS! Its sad when the truth is thrown up in there faces They are frauding there own people & families and have not morals in there bodies to correct it. They violated many peoples civil rights and have not paid for it. We need to get Indian civil rights so corrupt officials can get dealt with. Yes I am upset about it all it is fustrating I want to stand up for my elders and those that cant stand. I have taken bear gas been also set afire in a building seen my nephew stabbed trying to help an elder bring in coffee and donuts at a peaceful protest against a blocked election. I dont know if I have to become a martor and die for the cause to get national attention and a resoluation and really if I could do that. I left non profit and moved on to private sector to support myself and my children. I didnt want to depend on tribal stipends and programs. I feel fustranted that Madera County feels compeld to continue to support there CASH COW and turn a blind eye to all of the corruption and human /civils rights violations done to the peaceful protesters inside the building. My GOD I watched in horror as Reggie Lewis handed one of his Security Goons the yellow chainsaw handsaw and black duffle bags filled with the bear spray cans and tasers to attack us on the backside of the building as it turned dark. (on Casino side media was present and know one allowed in of area, so media could not witness the bad they were instilling upon us inside) Any Suggestions would be welcomed Im still willing to help my people but Im at a stay still and to date lewis and ramirez wyatt have taken over governent building on 2/21/13 at 8 pm??? What can we do against the opressors of the tribe? Lord Help Us JESUS!
3