A Different View of Mount Rushmore


There are several variations on the image above, which contrasts the faces of U.S. Presidents on Mount Rushmore with those of famous Native leaders. (This one happens to come from Julian Lennon's Facebook page.)

Below are a few more examples of the concept, as well as some information on the legacy of Mount Rushmore:

Mount Rushmore

Mount Rushmore

Mount Rushmore

Mount Rushmore

The re-imagining of Mount Rushmore goes beyond disputes about, for instance, who should be considered the "real" founding fathers -- Mount Rushmore is located in the Black Hills, land that i sacred to a number of tribes. It's also land that, according to the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, was to belong to American Indians forever. But after an expedition led by General Custer discovered gold there in 1874, the Fort Laramie Treaty was soon scrapped and the Lakota relocated to reservations.

The Lakota and others say that Mount Rushmore isn't just a piece of art they dislike; it's a piece of art they dislike that, to put it in European terms, has been forcibly installed in their own church.

The Need to Know

Native American Netroots has an extensive post on Mount Rushmore that is worthwhile reading. Here are a few interesting facts from it:

  • Mount Rushmore was known to the Sioux as Six Grandfathers. It was given the name "Rushmore" on a whim, in 1884, when New York City attorney Charles E. Rushmore asked what it was called.
  • The idea of a giant sculptural monument was dreamed up by South Dakota historian Doane Robinson in 1923; his original vision was an homage to historical figures from the American West, including George Armstrong Custer, Meriwether Lewis, William Clark, and even Chief Red Cloud.
  • From 2004-2010, the superintendent of the park was Gerard Baker, Mandan/Hidatsa), previously superintendent at the Little Bighorn Battlefield in Montana. When offered the job, Baker consulted tribal leaders who told him that having a Native in the position would be a step toward healing the wounds of history. Baker initiated a number of efforts to make tourists aware of the land's value to Natives.

A Fifth Face?

Ben Black Elk

There was, for more than 27 years, an acknowledged fifth face of Mount Rushmore: Ben Black Elk, famous as an on-site ambassador of Lakota culture until his death in 1973. Click here for more about Ben Black Elk.

Place of Protest

During the heyday of the American Indian Movement, Natives held a number of protests at Mount Rushmore -- at one point rechristening it Crazy Horse Mountain. The video below shows two news clips from the era; the first is coverage of the National Congress of American Indians in 1969, featuring some strong words from Lehman Brightman of the United Native Americans. The second half of the video is a news report about a protest at Mount Rushmore that began in August 1970.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



normanmicco's picture
Submitted by normanmicco on
Was this issue ever decided in Congress or federal courts? If not why not and where do I go for more information?

Lou Ann Terry's picture
Lou Ann Terry
Submitted by Lou Ann Terry on
does anyone know if these are posters for sale and if so where I can get one?

Steve Ogden
Steve Ogden
Submitted by Steve Ogden on
I just shared this, with the following comments: Excuse me?! Who among us non-natives would stand for even a fraction of what the natives of Turtle Island went though... some ludicrous and completely irrelevant culture imposing their "rightness" on us? Anyway, if you have an open mind and a love for history, you'll be interested in this take on Mount Rushmore. From a 1969 newsreel imbedded in the article: "American Indians are becoming militant... the administration is aware of this new militancy... Secretary of the Interior... who is in charge of Indian Affairs, has set out along with Vice President Agnew to reassure the Indians that the Great White Father will provide for them." ------ I get that some or your readers may find my presence offensive, but that's about them, not me. I have a strong sense of justice, and almost anything along these lines just boils my blood!