The 1627 letter from Pieter Schaghen, the representative of the States General in the Assembly of the West India Company, detailing the sale of Manhattan Island for 60 guilders.

Columbia Native Students Demand Recognition of Original Inhabitants

Simon Moya-Smith


Students of the Native American Council at Columbia University in New York City were poised to take back Manhattan with a pow wow on April 14. Now, they are demanding that the Ivy League institution honor the original inhabitants of Manhattan with a plaque.

On April 24, the students submitted an online petition to change.org. The petition reads: “’For Alma Mater on the Hudson Shore,’ we ask Columbia University to fund a plaque on the Morningside Heights campus acknowledging the Lenni Lenape people to whom we owe a debt by virtue of our sitting, standing, and learning on lands that were originally theirs.”

Tristin Moone, a Diné and member of the Native American Council, said the council members approached administrators in the fall to request the plaque.

Moone said the school’s response was, “We’ll think about it.”

She added, though, that the university is in dialogue with council members about its resources available to Native students.

“The university has reciprocated our demands for improving Native student services by initiating an audit of programs and services for Native students at Columbia,” she said.

Still, for Moone, the plaque is needed.

“Lady Liberty (the Statue of Liberty) is just down south of us,” she said. “Having something that is equally permanent, that can be a memorial … a recognition of the first peoples, would certainly mean just as much as any other temporary help that the school can give us.”

The Native American students at Columbia University are not alone in their endeavor to get school administrators to publicly acknowledge indigenous claims to land.

According to Moone, the idea was agreed upon at the All Ivy Council Summit, hosted in February at the University of Pennsylvania.

The All Ivy Council Summit is a gathering of all the Native American student organizations at each of the eight Ivy League universities.

Cornell University senior Mia R. McKie, Tuscarora, co-chair of the Native American Students at Cornell (NASAC), said her organization hopes to goad Cornell administrators into acknowledging the original inhabitants of what is now Ithaca, New York.

McKie said that the city of Ithaca was established on Cayuga territory. She added that Cornell administrators have yet to agree to NASAC’s requests that the university recognize the Cayuga people during graduation commencements and on their website.

NASAC does not seek the establishment of a plaque, but verbal and written recognition, McKie said.

McKie added that NASAC’s request has stalled due to the university’s “fear of land claims.”

“We are continually finding other methods to get our message across,” she said.

Meanwhile, at Columbia University, the Native students are taking to the Web via Facebook and Twitter to market their petition, which at the time of this publication has garnered more than 300 signatures.

“Our students are extraordinary engaged, collaborative. They continue to enliven dialogue all around this campus,” said Assistant Professor Audra Simpson, professor of anthropology at Columbia University and a Kahnawake Mohawk.

Simpson said she hopes Columbia’s administration will acknowledge the petition and establish a plaque to honor the Lenape people.

“That’s the least they can do,” she said, adding that it is not incorrect to state that Columbia University resides on traditional Lenape territory.

“It’s a matter of fact,” she said, “and Columbia is in the business of facts.”

Simpson encourages all Native students, including those attending other universities, to acknowledge the power they possess.

“You can move mountains with reason,” she said. “I’m excited for the world they are creating.”

Likewise, Moone said she’s optimistic that the plaque will be established and that the administrators will understand the importance of what recognizing the first inhabitants of Manhattan would mean for future Columbia students.

“We can only hope,” she said.

Native American Council Treasurer Julian Brave NoiseCat said he plans to reach out to the Lenape people for support.

He added that the next step is to secure an audience with Columbia University President Lee Bollinger.

Columbia University did not respond to requests for comment.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



White Clay's picture
White Clay
Submitted by White Clay on
Forensic science has proven that the earliest inhabitants of what is now called the United States were Japanese Islanders landing on the west coast and Europeans on the east coast. This is before the glaciers melted that blocked passage to Mongolians crossing the Bering Strait. What status should be accorded to these 'original inhabitants'?

Myron Paine's picture
Myron Paine
Submitted by Myron Paine on
[Irrefutable statements with links to evidence and testimony.] Vikings were in North America 1,000 years ago. The Vikings called themselves "LENAPE." Lenape were still in western Minnesota in 1362 Lenape, Shawnee and 23 kindred tribes still live in America. The oldest American history was composed by the LENAPE.  See LENAPE LAND for the first 38 of 144 stanzas. Starting with the Little Ice Age the Lenape migrated 4,000 miles and 150 years to reach Manhattan.  They were Christians when they started. They were Christians when the Invaders came. They remain Christians. Some funds should be used to preserve the oldest American history of a valiant people, who remain survivors even in a land they no longer control.  Myron Paine, Ph. D., Author 

Ray Cook's picture
Ray Cook
Submitted by Ray Cook on
Certain Universities were established as land grant institutions. What is the definition of a land grant institution?

Hersh's picture
Submitted by Hersh on
It's understanding to believe the notion that the aboriginal peoples of North America may have migrated from various parts of the world such as Asia, Ice land, Viking voyages, etc...which I believe is a result based on the western theory of science... but what I don't understand is why aren't Indigenous oral stories, as we all know Indigenous people (American Indians) have occupied the lands prior to European contact, taken into account when we talk about who where the true aboriginal peoples of the lands. I believe they have a tremendous understanding of how the land was and also the historical events which took place here prior to European studies (Anthropology, Geography, etc...) input into what history holds here in America...so if the academic world can only respect what the Indigenous view point is, I believe we can truly understand to respect the real historic events which unfolded in North America...

Rochelle Smetherham's picture
Rochelle Smetherham
Submitted by Rochelle Smetherham on
Was there ever a plaque or memorial to honor the Lenape in the Capitols of these states? What about in PA? Also there needs to be a good memorial for the genocide in Gnadenhutten massacre? Are their any put up in special place in the country where a good one is established and Lenape honored? I would love to know to further ask congress to do it. [email protected]

Ipad ケース's picture
Ipad ケース
Submitted by Ipad ケース on
2013.creating a . pherobase. arguing that both opponents and supporters of the law had an obligation to make it work. noting that small businesses will only get tax credits for insuring up to 25 employees.

jordan pas cher's picture
jordan pas cher
Submitted by jordan pas cher on
We should also mention that the current Republican strategy mirrors an approach Democrats used when they were confident their party would win the presidency in 2008. Anthony Rendon, Bryce Harper shifts over to center field and will hit leadoff.into two publicly traded companies one servicing government-backed loans and the other making private loans to strengthen its business the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Awareness of technology’s constant temptation? Grammys or Super Bowl.Traffic has been at a standstill since about 3 a. The right lane remains closed.Drivers are advised to find an alternate route if possibleUpdate 6:14 am:The three left lanes of northbound I-95 have reopened leaving only the right lane closed according to the Maryland State Highway AdministrationOfficials said major delays remain extending back to the Howard County line? Microsoft will acquire 32.