Is the Navajo Mine a Viable Option? Growing Opposition Doesn’t Think So

Alysa Landry

Yazzie is pushing for drastic action in the Navajo Nation Council, where investigations into fraudulent spending are ongoing. If he fails to get the purchase reversed within council chambers or with help from the Interior Department, Yazzie is prepared to take the matter to court.

Yazzie is just one of many Navajo citizens appealing for intervention from federal leaders. Two grassroots groups of environmental activists also are seeking support from Washington, D.C., to stop or reverse the purchase.

Diné CARE – or Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment – wants to halt the purchase until an environmental impact statement is completed. The Interior Department’s Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement is preparing that statement, with release expected sometime this spring.

RELATED: Diné CARE opposing ‘Bad Business Decision’ That Is the Navajo Mine

Lori Goodman, treasurer for Diné CARE, fears the statement will reveal significant risks to the environment and to human health. Among those risks, she said, is the 100 million tons of coal ash created by the power plant and contamination of nearby water supplies. This statement is the first to be released in 50 years, Goodman said.

“It might turn out that mining coal is not viable,” she said. “Then there’s a huge liability looming for the Navajo Nation. This could bankrupt us.”

Another grassroots group that has taken stands against fossil fuels is Dooda Desert Rock, an organization that sprang up in response to the tribe’s plans in 2003 to build a coal-fired power plant about 25 miles south of Farmington. The plant, Desert Rock, would have been the third on reservation land, but it failed to come to fruition.

Elouise Brown, president of Dooda, said she opposes the mine purchase for the same reasons she fought against Desert Rock. Brown recently lost her father to health problems linked to his work in uranium mines, and she believes a new generation of disease and death is coming for those who work in the mine.

“Health needs to be the main concern,” she said. “Health of people, the environment and all living creatures.”


You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



bullbear's picture
Submitted by bullbear on
Coal is one of the "dirtiest" sources of natural resources that there is. It requires mammoth amounts of water to process that leaves contamination that effects all life it comes in contact with. The contaminated water will effect the health of people for generations. As Dineh, our forefathers did not leave us all the ill-effects of horrible industries such as this and we should do everything in our power to ensure our children and their children have the same privilege. The EPA is at work devising emission control plans to limit carbon dioxide that power plants emit. Obama expects it to be in place by 2017. We are kidding ourselves if they think the mind-boggling amounts of air pollutants is not effecting melting glaciers, heat waves, and rising of sea. Alternate energy is what is being called for. Solar power? Wind power? If we are not turning our minds in this direction, we will be playing catch-up and left with catastrophic medical needs that tribes are already struggling to meet.