Max D. Stanley Trail of Tears
Max D.Stanley
“The Trail of Tears,” historical oil painting by Max D. Standley, commissioned oil on panel painting created 1995, size of oil painting: 36" X 60.” This recently deceased painter did a series of four paintings on the Trail Of Tears, you can see all four at

Trail of Tears: From a Middle School Student's Perspective


This persuasive essay was submitted to ICTMN by Matthew Scraper, Megan Scraper’s father. Megan, 12, is a student at Marlow Middle School in Oklahoma. They are citizens of the Cherokee Nation, and Matthew pointed out that their last name is an English translation of the Cherokee word “disugasgi,” which means something along the lines of “the one who repeatedly scrapes the skin.” She chose to write about the Trail of Tears on her own when given a class assignment.

Imagine you are a little girl in the late 1830s. You and your family had lived in the Cherokee tribe for generations. Then one day when you returned from playing in the fields, you find your family gone and your house is ransacked. A short time later you get placed inside a cattle stockade, and after a few months you realize you’ll never see your family again.

This is what happened to a lot of small kids on that dreadful day. It was painful for many Indians to watch their lands taken, the people die, and have to watch their people abused and mistreated. This was a very bad time for Native Americans. The Trail of Tears was the biggest crime against the indigenous population, the crime that wasn’t considered a crime.

The Trail of Tears set a national precedent for the confiscation of Indian lands. What this means is it started the Removal Era, and later the Land Run Era that included land that had once been Cherokee without any respect for the people who lived there before. They wanted the land for a few reasons, but a couple are: farming, and belief in the existence of gold. They were told that it would only happen once, but it continued on with different tribes later, after it happened during the Trail of Tears.

A fact you may not know is that the Trail of Tears represented the largest percentage of deaths within a single indigenous tribe due to the action of the U.S. government in American Indian history. This killed around 4,000 members of the Cherokee tribe. These people died because of lots of reasons: poor weather conditions, little food and water, long walks with little rest, sickness with no medicine, and lastly being killed by soldiers.

This is a word that people use when someone tries to wipe out an entire race: genocide. That happened to these people, my people, it was very hard for them for many reasons, but they weren’t allowed to give their loved ones proper burial rites, they had to bury them on the side of the Trail and then just keep walking. Can you imagine having to bury a family member on the side of the road and then just having to leave them there? The deaths of these people, my people, were very hard on the Indians. The name of the Trail of Tears actually came from a Cherokee phrase that meant “the place where they cried.”

Lastly, the Trail of Tears set a precedent for the subhuman treatment of indigenous people by the U.S. government. This means that it justified the abusive treatment toward Indians. When they were gathered up in cattle stockades, in the mud with a bunch of diseases, many other things happened as well: women were raped, people were separated from their families, they were beaten, and they were killed. It wasn’t right and it wasn’t fair, but there was nothing the tribes could do. The soldiers were mean, cruel, and in my personal opinion, acted like the British soldiers did before America declared independence from Britain. The people were treated with disrespect, and one of the only reasons this happened was because the government decided that land and gold were more important than Indian lives.

In conclusion, the people who were forced to undergo the Trail of Tears were treated with injustice. The Trail of Tears set a precedent for the confiscation of Indian lands, represented the largest percentage of deaths within a single indigenous tribe as a result of action taken by the U.S. government, and set a precedent for the subhuman treatment of Indian people by the U.S. government. These reasons support the opinion: The Trail of Tears was the biggest crime against the indigenous population, and after reading this essay you might be thinking, “I agree.” Well, good. Now that you know this, take care and make sure that it never happens again.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



sweetmystique's picture
Submitted by sweetmystique on
Congratulations Ms. Scraper. You are well on your way to becoming a storyteller! Tim Tingle also wrote a Trail of Tears story from a child's perspective and it's beautiful as well as haunting. It's a short story in his book, "Walking The Choctaw Road," so you're in good company. Keep up the good work!

Juliet's picture
Submitted by Juliet on
I've long thought it an injustice, especially when the history books tried to justify it with implications that the Cherokee 'weren't doing anything with' the land while the whites would farm it. It was theft, plain and simple, regardless of who was doing what with the land -- and the Cherokee were farming it, which means the theft saved the new owners a lot of effort. Sigh.

Michael Madrid's picture
Michael Madrid
Submitted by Michael Madrid on
Kudos to Ms. Scraper! It's too bad that the average White kid in American schools will NEVER learn Native history, but I'm extra enthused when a Native child knows the history of her people! The Cherokee were proof that the invaders simply wanted their lands and didn't care one bit about "civilizing the savages!" The Cherokee were successful farmers, statesmen and businessmen, but that didn't stop the expedient excuses to move them from their homeland. The "we want you to farm the land and be productive Christians" was just as much bullshit as the assertion that "all men are created equal!" ____________________________________________________________ Sadly, Native history with it's embarrassing episodes like The Trail of Tears, the Long Walk, Sand Creek, Wounded Knee I & II, Popay and the Pueblo Revolt and the NDN Boarding Schools will NEVER be taught in American schools. It's the advantage of the conquerer to rewrite history to make himself look good.

Grayhorse's picture
Submitted by Grayhorse on
I think History should be rewritten to tell the truth about what really happened to the Indians. It's sad this happened and so many lost their lives. It's sad that people mistreat other people so badly and nothing is done about it. When I read stories like this, about the way the Government and the soldiers, what they did to the Indians, brings tears to my eyes.

suzette_brewer's picture
Submitted by suzette_brewer on
Wa do gahooch, skasdi! What a well-written and heartfelt piece. I hope we see more of your work in the future, Ms. Scraper. Well done. :)