Associated Press
Oil train derailments such as this one from November 7, 2015, in Wisconsin are an all too common sight, the Quinault Nation says.

Quinault Raise Alarm Yet Again After Two Oil Trains Derail in One Weekend


Two more derailments of oil-bearing trains last weekend, both in Wisconsin, have prompted the Quinault Nation to issue yet another warning about the dangers inherent in such transport.

“The frequency of these train crashes combined with the danger they pose to people and to the environment that sustains us should alarm everyone, everywhere, to the point that they take a stand against increased oil train traffic,” said Quinault Nation President Fawn Sharp in a statement on Tuesday November 10.

Her declaration came after 13 cars of a Canadian Pacific Railway train derailed on Sunday November 8, puncturing a tank car, which leaked oil. That accident unleashed about 1,000 gallons of crude oil, and residents of Watertown, Wisconsin had to evacuate. Of the 110 cars, 109 were carrying crude oil, according to the Associated Press.

“The company claimed no oil reached a waterway, neglecting to report damages to land or underground aquifers,” the Quinault statement noted, adding that 35 residents had to leave their homes.

The evacuations were conducted as a precaution, and the residents have since returned, Reuters reported. The company said a broken rail had caused the incident.

The second accident involved 25 cars on a Burlington Northern Santa Fe (BNSF) Railway Co. train that derailed about 200 miles away near Alma, Wisconsin, dumping about 18,500 gallons of ethanol into the Mississippi River, according to Reuters.

Sharp said that such accidents underscore the dangers of transporting oil and other chemicals by rail, as well as the difficulties inherent in responding to such emergencies, especially in remote areas. The Quinault and numerous other tribes, including the Swinomish, have spoken out strongly against the transport of oil by rail, especially through remote, ecologically sensitive areas.

RELATED: Swinomish Tribe Files Lawsuit to Stop Bakken Crude Oil Trains

“Although railroad crews say they stopped the leaks from the five tanker cars near Alma and placed containment booms along the shoreline, and are attempting to downplay the impacts, that remains questionable,” Sharp said, pointing out that 15 refineries and port terminals are being planned, built or are already operating in Oregon and Washington alone.

RELATED: New Brunswick Oil Train Wreck Draws More Rail-Transport Criticism

“There were no human injuries reported—this time,” Sharp said of the two derailments. “But regardless of the reports from the railroad companies, the writing is on the wall. Train accidents involving fossil fuel spills have happened over and over again all across this country, and the number of ultra-long trains carrying these dangerous payloads has increased exponentially. All of this has been going on as the impacts of climate change are clearly increasing. Oil companies are proposing more and more such trains, even as we struggle with our efforts to restore and protect clean water and habitat for fish and wildlife.”

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



Wultenviron's picture
Submitted by Wultenviron on
“We can’t fix every problem or guarantee there will be no more accidents. But that's no reason to stay on the sidelines. We should get into the game. The state needs to work with the railroads and the feds, and invest in the safety of the rail system that is vital to our economy and runs through the heart of so many North Dakota communities. (The writer is chairman of the North Dakota Public Service Commission, Julie Fedorchak.)” Track failures are linked to 31 percent of all train accidents, and even though such incidents are becoming less common, prevention remains critical, said Federal Railroad Administration spokesman Mike Booth. It’s especially important with a 400 percent increase in more volatile Bakken crude oil being shipped out of the North Dakota region. Railroads are required by law to inspect and maintain their equipment in good repair, and the Federal Railroad Administration ensures that by auditing records and doing spot inspections, Booth said. Statistically, the probability of an oil train derailment is very low and lower than other forms of transportation. But the potential undesirable consequences are relatively high, including damage to human life, property and the environment. Environmental and economic impacts, however, were substantial. Recent reports have noted that the amount of oil spilled in 2013 alone from train derailments, at more than 1.1 million gallons, was greater than the total amount of oil spilled from 1975 to 2012. The Federal Railroad Administration enforces the health and safety regulations under which the railroads operate. But they have been more indulgent and less strict than they should be, given the increase in crude oil cargoes and their extreme volatility. Tell them to do their jobs, to protect the citizens, not just the railroad shareholders. Sign the petition at