Belinda Ayze, Navajo, of Flagstaff, Arizona, holds a protest sign during a rally on December 21 to oppose snowmaking with treated wastewater on the San Francisco Peaks.

Protests Against Arizona Snowbowl Continues As Ski Season Begins

Anne Minard
December 24, 2012


Hardy activists braved single-digit temperatures in Flagstaff on December 21 to protest Arizona Snowbowl, the resort atop the sacred San Francisco Peaks that will soon blanket its slopes with snow made from reclaimed wastewater.

Tribal and environmental opponents of snowmaking toted signs with the slogans “Protect Sacred Sites, Defend Human Rights,” and “Danger: Shi*tBowl; Health Hazard” in front of Flagstaff City Hall, during an all-day protest meant to coincide with the kickoff of Snowbowl’s 75th ski season this week. It will be the first season during which the resort will spray the treated effluent on a site held sacred by 13 tribes.

“What needs to happen is the government needs to afford the same rights to Native Americans that everybody else in this country enjoys,” said Klee Benally, a long-time Navajo activist on behalf of the San Francisco Peaks. He believes the failure to protect the mountain is a violation of freedom of religion for people who consider it holy.

Protester Belinda Ayze, Navajo, said this issue is one in a series that activists in her family have been publicizing and protesting for generations.

“My grandparents were activists for freedom of religion,” she said. “When I was 4 years old, they were fighting for the Native American Church, schools, civil rights movements. I grew up with all these issues and they’re still going on. I’m a grandma now.”

Protests over Arizona Snowbowl date back to the 1960s and 1970s, when tribal activists opposed the basic concept of building ski slopes on the mountain. Since snowmaking was first proposed in the early 2000s, anti-snowmaking activists have lobbied the U.S. Forest Service and the courts to stop it; they’ve been thwarted, so far, each time.

“Snowbowl has nothing to say about the continued protests,” J.R. Murray, general manager at Snowbowl, wrote in an e-mail on December 21. “Thousands of citizens enjoy their public land. We are honored to provide a quality winter recreational experience.”

But opponents aren’t giving up.

Most recently, the Hopi Tribe filed a civil action in November asking the U.S. Forest Service to withdraw its permission for snowmaking until it completes ongoing consultations with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The consultations were re-opened after the Hopi Tribe commissioned a study showing threats to an endangered plant, the San Francisco Peaks groundsel, hadn’t been adequately considered.

And several activists are facing charges in federal District Court after they delivered protest letters to Forest Service officials at their Flagstaff offices in September – and allegedly dumped a bucket of reclaimed wastewater on the floor as they walked out. Flagstaff residents Klee Benally, Dawn Dyer, Michael Anders and Evan Hawbaker are charged with violating a statute that prohibits “threatening, resisting, intimidating, or interfering with any forest officer engaged in or on account of the performance of his official duties in the protection, improvement, or administration of the National Forest System.” Each count carries a maximum sentence of up to six months in prison, a $5,000 fine and probation lasting up to five years. The defendants will next appear in court on December 27 for status conferences that could begin their trials.

“This issue isn’t over,” Benally said at Friday’s protest. “This political attack and my arrest don’t deter me at all from doing what I need to do to make sure our cultural practices are protected.”


Submitted by Anonymous on

Snowbowl has started making snow and it is YELLOW!!

Check out www[dot]truesnow[dot]org to see real pictures


Submitted by Anonymous on

I love Flagstaff been there many times. I love the Indians, we need to respect their wishes. They have rights like we do.

Submitted by Anonymous on

These are meant to be clever people why cant they learn from indigenous 'why we protest' you dont mix unclean with clean papatuanuku is our mother (whenua land)...You only have to look around the world unreal tidal waves,earh quakes,spewing ugly sewage into the sea,raping of the land, and wiping generations so it goes on. Totally tautoko(support) what you are doing protect your cultural practices little lady from Whanganui Leonie

Submitted by Anonymous on

Intrerestingly, the water industry's own research arm, the Water Environment Research Foundation released a report specifically discussing the finding numerous tupes of pathogens in reclaimed water that met Arizona standards. The report and the later peer reviewed journal article on the same subject noted that the standards did not protect public health. That report came out is 2004, which would seem adequate to forewarn the USFS that there were potentially serious health issues associated with reclaimed water.

Dr Edo McGowan, Merdical Geo-hydrology

Add new comment

Court Cases
Headline News
Sacred Sites

Around The Web

Huge storm system blamed for 3 deaths, moves east
Children, many ill, would be victims of Russia ban on U.S. adoption
Jessica Simpson's Christmas gift: She's pregnant
Study Finds Modest Declines in Obesity Rates Among Young Children From Poor Families