iStock images
Illegal marijuana grows have been using hefty portions of scarce river water in those counties, threatening both water resources and salmon habitats.

Marijuana vs. Salmon? Climate Change May Be Forcing Tough Choice

Jacqueline Keeler
6/2/15

A perfect storm is converging on the tribes of the “Emerald Triangle,” the name given to the three counties – Humboldt, Mendocino and Trinity – in Northern California where much of the country’s marijuana is grown, hidden under canopies of trees. After four years of drought, the worst in California’s history, a State Department of Fish and Wildlife report published in March found that illegal marijuana grows have been using hefty portions of scarce river water in those counties, threatening both water resources and salmon habitats. Meanwhile, the U.S. Department of Justice has signaled to federally recognized tribes that under certain guidelines tribal cannabis cultivation and sales will not be prosecuted.

For many tribal members the option of going into the cannabis business is a choice between economic growth and maintaining salmon habitats.

Yurok tribal chairman, Thomas P. O'Rourke Sr. told ICTMN that a marijuana plant, “takes a lot of cold water from the Klamath River. One plant takes three gallons of water per day and the plant’s life is five months. That’s 450 gallons for one plant – 1,000 plants a small number, is 450,000 gallons. Multiply that by hundreds and cold water destined for our rivers is diverted and the adverse effects on our resources is a major issue. [Illegal grows] not only detour water from river but use poisons for pest eradication (varmints). Poison then enters back into spring.”

Both the Yurok and Hoopa tribes have taken part in raids on illegal grows with federal and state agencies, eliminating tens of thousands of marijuana plants. In a Los Angeles Times article last year about the raids, Josh Norris, a Yurok tribal member said, “There are elders living near some of these grows with no telephone and without reliable transportation, and they’re scared.”

O’Rourke told ICTMN, “Because of our resources, unsavory people have been brought into our lands and our women and children are no longer able to gather basket materials and foods, people with guns point at our children and women. Staff can’t do jobs because of illegal pot growers out there.”

In fact, biologists and foresters working with the Hoopa tribe were fired upon while conducting nighttime spotted-owl surveys. After the tribe alerted the police, helicopter reconnaissance discovered an illegal grow about a mile long.

Some tribal leaders see things differently: former Hoopa tribal chairman, Clifford Lyle Marshall wrote an editorial in a local paper urging the Hoopa tribe to repeal Title 34, the Marijuana Cultivation Suppression Ordinance, which allows the tribe to search and seize property, impose fines, and banish tribal members for cultivation of marijuana.

Marshall noting that the tribe was once blamed for killing the salmon in the 1970s, stated, “Nothing that the marijuana gardens may have used is comparable to the hundreds of thousands of acre-feet of water diverted to the Central Valley Project, and it does a disservice to the issue of environmental protection to simply blame a scapegoat... Permitting our citizens to grow on their property eliminates the reason people grow in the mountains, which is to hide. Legitimate farmers won’t have to hide if they can farm their own land. For this economically depressed community, the decision of the DOJ is nothing less than providence.“

On April 28, the Hoopa tribe in Humboldt County voted down a measure 534 to 308 to repeal Title 34 that makes marijuana production illegal on the reservation. Lisa Sundberg, a Yurok tribal member and cannabis entrepreneur told ICTMN, “They missed the opportunity to regulate it. All of these tribes have bars and sell alcohol. Every one of these Rancherias has some kind of alcohol and cigarettes they sell in their retail shops. This needs to be put in proper perspective, and regulation is the answer.”

She points out that regulations would weed out irresponsible growers and ensure that cannabis cultivation occurs only where there is adequate water. “That will only happen when there are rules that everyone understands what they are. Nobody knows now. As long as there are no requirements for anyone to do, all of these practices are going to continue. Bad behaviors are ongoing because these guys did not regulate and chose to go zero tolerance so they are going to all underground, and you can’t distinguish between bad actors and responsible ones.”

She notes that out of a 134,000 population in Humboldt County the number of grows, 14,000, is a huge engagement. A Vice investigation last year asserted nearly a fifth of Humboldt’s population is engaged in marijuana production.

Sundberg urges tribes to legitimize the industry and institute responsible zoning. “Tribes are not making a dime off of anyone that’s growing,” she says, “Eradication is a band-aid and it would cost them more money than if they regulated it. And it criminalizes tribal members: there is nothing else to grow.”

Tribal laws not only criminalize growers but also tribal members who are cancer patients with medical prescriptions legal in the rest of the state of California. She contrasts that with the heavy use of prescription opioids on the reservation that are given out by the Indian Health Service. Native Americans have the highest rates of prescription opioid addiction. Interestingly, recent studies have found that cannabis can help with getting off of opioids.

In the southern part of the Emerald Triangle in Mendocino County, the Pinoleville Pomo Nation stands apart from its neighbors in developing the first and largest indoor grow facility in Indian country. As reported by ICTMN in January, they have partnered with Kansas-based Foxbury Farm and United Cannabis out of Colorado to build a $30 million grow facility.

Sundberg notes, “Humboldt County has the best product and most experience in the country. Sixty years of growers and its product is tried and tested and is the international brand of medical marijuana in the world. Out of that has to come best practices. We need leadership in Indian country to set the pace to building this framework.”

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page

POST A COMMENT

Comments

mrsoulco's picture
mrsoulco
Submitted by mrsoulco on
This article is hard to swallow on several levels--the title alone misrepresents a fundamental idea about salmon tribes and creates some sort of impossible dichotomy that is misleading. Salmon tribes are not salmon tribes out of convenience, simply waiting for a lucrative marijuana cash crop to replace their reliance and relationship with salmon. What this article fails to appreciate is that Pacific salmon are in danger and that illegal marijuana grows are a real threat every year, particularly in years like this one in Northern California, where water demand is high and illegal grows literally suck up entire tributaries that are critical for river flows during spawning season. Chairman O'Rourke is exactly right and the Yurok Tribe should be concerned: it's a safety and environmental issue, not an anti-marijuana issue. And I think Chairman Marshall is making irresponsible statements that -- although it is true that the California central valley takes water it doesn't deserve -- belittle the issue and that potentially creates a crisis on the Klamath River for the native communities in the name of making a quick buck. Yes, marijuana and salmon can coexist and similarly help tribes. But, if a tribe chooses not to legalize it, that is their right, just like most of your states. The rug legal marijuana is currently on could be pulled out pretty quickly, and this article seems to try to marginalize the issue in a short-sighted money grab. I live in Colorado, so I understand the benefits of legal marijuana, but this article (and this paper's job covering marijuana in Indian Country, generally) needs to do a much better job at presenting the real issues (environmental effects, enforcement, regulation, health pros/cons) and not the sensationalized ones aimed at promoting a pro-marijuana agenda.

Carlos Olivares Pérez
Carlos Olivares...
Submitted by Carlos Olivares... on
"Interestingly, recent studies have found that cannabis can help with getting off of opioids" Can you please share this studies?

kalidescopemind's picture
kalidescopemind
Submitted by kalidescopemind on
Many of tributaries used in Humbolt for grows are not dammed anywhere, so there is no magic solution. All farmer's water use is regulated by the State Water Resources Control board, and our salmon industry can only be described as devastated. You have to live on the coast to get any that isn't farm raised, or pay $25/lb. There is a lot of indoor growing springing up, so the 'Emerald Triangle" glory days are numbered. We still have the "CAMP" folks who are nostalgic for the para-military busts, we can do without that too.

kalidescopemind's picture
kalidescopemind
Submitted by kalidescopemind on
Many of tributaries used in Humbolt for grows are not dammed anywhere, so there is no magic solution. All farmer's water use is regulated by the State Water Resources Control board, and our salmon industry can only be described as devastated. You have to live on the coast to get any that isn't farm raised, or pay $25/lb. There is a lot of indoor growing springing up, so the 'Emerald Triangle" glory days are numbered. We still have the "CAMP" folks who are nostalgic for the para-military busts, we can do without that too.
4