Associated Press/Cliff Owen
Pope Francis at the canonization ceremony of Junípero Serra on September 23, 2015, in Washington D.C.

4 Native Entities That Opposed the Canonization of Junípero Serra (to No Avail)


Since Pope Francis first proposed canonizing Father Junípero Serra earlier this year, American Indians have been outraged, especially in California. On September 23, as the pontiff performed the ceremony at the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception, Native peoples protested all across Turtle Island.

In what they knew was a vain attempt to stop the process, numerous tribes and groups had registered their opposition to the move to canonize the Spanish friar, who built the first nine of what would eventually grow to a 21-mission system across California. Tens of thousands of people died in those missions, which opponents say were designed to “destroy the culture of the Native Americans,” as Valentin Lopez, chairman of the Amah Mutsun Tribal Band, put it to National Catholic Reporter. Below are some tribes and other groups who have come out publicly against the canonization.

Amah Mutsun Tribal Band

Spearheading the effort was the Amah Mutsun Tribal Band, whose leaders not only wrote letters but also launched a campaign to raise public awareness of Serra’s misdeeds, which included widespread abuse. Among the resources is a web page compiling media reports about the issue. The band also wrote a half dozen letters to Pope Francis, the latest in mid-September, outlining once again the numerous reasons against sainthood and requesting a meeting with the pontiff.

RELATED: Sainthood for Genocide Leader? Amah Mutsun Ask Pope Francis to Stop Junipero Serra Canonization

"We're stunned and we're in disbelief," Lopez told CNN after the canonization. "We believe saints are supposed to be people who followed in the life of Jesus Christ and the words of Jesus Christ. There was no Jesus Christ lifestyle at the missions.”

Suzan Shown Harjo, Morningstar Institute

The Medal of Freedom winner wrote an open letter to the pope last week, telling him outright not to go through with the canonization and to rescind the Doctrine of Discovery, the documents issued by the church in the 1500s that gave justification for the subjugation of non-Christians, including Indigenous Peoples of Turtle Island.

“It defies understanding that Pope Francis would apologize for past destruction of Native Peoples caused by the Catholic Church, yet leave in place the very documents that justify and make it possible for criminal assaults to continue against Native Peoples today,” Harjo wrote. “We entreat Pope Francis to rescind the anti-Indian Papal Bulls and Doctrine of Discovery, and to reverse the canonization of Father Junipero Serra.”

RELATED: Suzan Shown Harjo to Pope Francis: Don't Canonize Junípero Serra

Juaneno Band of Mission Indians, Acjachemen Nation

Earlier this month the Juaneno Band of Mission Indians, Acjachemen Nation, passed a resolution opposing the canonization and stipulating that the Pope rescind the Doctrine of Discovery. The band went a step beyond that to call for the Pope’s support of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

The tribe “formally opposes the Canonization of Junipero Serra due to his association with, uplifting of, and support for Church and State doctrinal policies aimed at the eradication of Indigenous cultural, linguistic, and spiritual beliefs and practices and the far reaching and long lasting negative impacts on the Indigenous Peoples of this hemisphere and around the world as a result of such policies and practices,” read part of the resolution, according to a media release from the band.

“The process of sainthood and canonization is symbolic—and Father Junipero Serra was a symbol of colonization. It is the uplifting of this symbol, particularly in light of Pope Francis’ recent apology to Indigenous peoples, to which we object,” said Tribal Chairman Matias Belardes in the statement. “Serra was a man of his time, and that time was a period during which the very humanity of our Ancestors was called into question by the legal and religious doctrines espoused by the Church and State. We do not believe that such a man, nor such a time period should be celebrated.”

Pechanga Band of Luiseño Indians (Pecháangayam Payómkawichum)

On September 22 the Pechanga Band of Luiseño Indians (Pecháangayam Payómkawichum) wrote an open letter to Pope Francis stating their opposition to Serra’s sainthood.

“In just one generation, the total population of all Payómkawichum (Luiseño) villages suffered a greater than 90 percent population loss through disease and abuse brought by Fr. Serra’s missionization,” the tribe stated. “Fr. Serra’s mission system killed between 9,000 and 13,500 of our ancestors. This rapid population loss in such a compressed time frame triggered a collapse of our indigenous societal structure and way of life and set into motion the atrocities and hardships that our people endured for nearly two centuries.”

The Pechanga are therefore “opposed to the canonization and glorification of Father Junipero Serra for the genocide, inhumane treatment and various crimes that Fr. Serra and his Spanish mission system committed against the ancestors of the Pechanga people,” the band said in their letter.

You need to be logged in in order to post comments
Please use the log in option at the bottom of this page



tmsyr11's picture
Submitted by tmsyr11 on
The power, might and influence of the collective Hispano voice of the Americas into the United States! With 11-20 MILLION illegal aliens (the majority) from through the 'open-door' pipeline of open borders, it was ONLY RIGHT and ONLY CORRECT to give to Hispanic interests what they have been asking for - for decades.

BWilson's picture
Submitted by BWilson on
How sad that the Catholic Church has once again turned a deaf ear to its crimes against humanity. I applaud the brave natives who have campaigned to get the truth about this so-called saint to the public.

idiotwind's picture
Submitted by idiotwind on
How would Pope Francis feel if he had to pray for spiritual help from a "saint" who spearheaded the genocide of his people? Seems fairly stupid to me.

moonlion's picture
Submitted by moonlion on
I was sad to hear someone make the comment that these things happened so long ago and people had different attitudes then, and Serra was a good man according to the beliefs of his time. Maybe I should add the comment horrified me, too, as well as making me sad. I've heard this kind of thing before and have never believed racism and evil acts can be forgiven based on "it's what people thought back then". It is wrong now. It was wrong then. I send appreciation to all those who made the effort to prevent the canonization of Junipero Serra. The effort was not wasted, even though the Catholic Church's action was not prevented.

c.grabowski's picture
Submitted by c.grabowski on
In addition to those mentioned in the article, there were many more tribes that wrote letters to the Pope in opposition to the canonization of Serra. In California alone these included: 30+ member tribes of the California Association of Tribal Governments (CATG) and the Southern California Tribal Chairmen's Association, Inc. which has 18 members. Tribes that wrote individually were: the Coastal Band of the Chumash Nation, Ewiiaapaayp band of Kumeyaay Indians, Mesa Grande, Los Coyotes Band of Indians, Mooretown Rancheria, Ohlone/Costanoan Esselen Nation, Winnemen Wintu Tribe. There are also prominent individuals who wrote letters opposing the canonization: for example, Suzan Harjo (Morningstar Institute) and Steven Newcomb (Indigenous Law Institute). The Quakers also had written a letter opposing the papal bulls and requesting that they be rescinded. In short, there are many who have not been and will not be silent regarding the true history of the California missions.

moonlion's picture
Submitted by moonlion on
Hello tmsy11, Responding to your comment below....I am sure a better person could have been found that Junipero Serra.

tmsyr11's picture
Submitted by tmsyr11 on
moonlion i dont disagree, but it was his Holiness Pope Francis that made the decision and his alone. What is disconcerting is how Pope Francis circumvented the Vatican practices of declaring a Saint. There were no supposed miracles and the timeframe was drastically cut down for Catholic sainthood. My question is why the rush for declaration? This decision was strictly for Pope Francis wanting ppls. everywhere to recognize and understand the contributions of hispanics to the Americas (Mexican and the other Europeans - Spain) . 20 MILL £illegal aliens and the subject of people migration affairs are more CRITICAL than fore-gone fables of native genocides, etc. This is just what the world body is focused on despite the outcrys and appeals of organized native groups and THOSE radical racial sypathizers.

nokomis's picture
Submitted by nokomis on
To tmsyr11: Why don't you sign in using your true face? Your clarification sucks...and just as I was beginning to respect Pope Francis! Kudos for the brave and courageous entities for voicing their opposition against the canonization. Makes me proud, today--to be indigenous and that the descendants have survived, despite the obstacles and setbacks.